I guess my standards must be lower than yours! For coins like these, I am really attracted to that peripheral toning pattern, the 1829 shows it more than the 25, but it's there. Beyond that, I don't really get too hung up on the details. These two I bought from JJ Teaparty, and all I saw was a photo of the 25, and Gail assured me that the 29 was even better and that I was sure to like it, and she was correct! I actually like the 29 a lot more and it cost less!