Jump to content
CoinPeople.com

schutzenfester

Members
  • Posts

    548
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by schutzenfester

  1. Here is the relatively common R179 (M104) 1830 Bern shooting medal. I have two photos, one of a real R179 and one of a counterfeit piece. The counterfeit was struck in ca. 1890. Schützenfest medals were so prized and collected that many counterfeits were struck years ago. I have encountered several counterfeits since I began collecting, the R179 is one of the more documented ones.

     

    For me the easiest way to determine if the piece is original is to check/compare the mountains; there is noticeable difference. Another way is the inspect the numeral 7 in the date, 7 Jul 1830. The style of the 7 (bottom of the trunk) is completely different. The numeral 2 ( in the number 12) before the date is also a point of difference. And if you inspect the medal in its entirety you will find many differences throughout.

     

     

    1830 Bern

    R179a / M104

    Federal Shoot

    Silver

    H / 28mm

     

     

    4e161f35.gif

     

     

    0ec08d71.jpg

     

     

     

     

    Here are easier side by side pictures of obverse and reverse to compare:

     

    c534b990.jpg

     

     

    bf3d13d3.jpg

  2. 1898 SWISS SHOOTING R-1029c, AR, 45mm NIDWALDEN - ENNET FEST PF 64 CA

     

    Resized to 97% (was 1024 x 393) - Click image to enlargeDSCN9408-horz.jpg

    I find it curious that NGC would grade this medal proof when if they did some research they would find that schützenfest medals were not minted in what we today call proof dies. It may look like proof; ”Proof Like” perhaps but not proof, the medal is Mint State. NGC can grade but it is too bad they don't have the global knowledge of what they are grading...I suppose it falls under some criteria that NGC calls proof, I not sure. Nevertheless, the medal itself is beautiful and the engraving is wonderful!

  3. Hi Kim,

     

    Your Bern medal is beautiful and I would say that the medal presently on eBay can't compare to yours.

    The one on the bay in some respects looks similar... ;)

     

    1910 Bern (R-263a) GOLD medal spotted on eBay.....

     

    http://cgi.ebay.com/...e=STRK:MEWAX:IT

     

    Way overpriced and (unless it's just a very bad scan) not only cleaned but the obverse has been polished to the extent that many details are missing.

     

    Nevertheless, if you have the money and want a gold Bern, this is your chance. Make him an offer.

     

    Feel free to use this photo of mine to compare the obverse details.....

     

    1136207_Full_Obv.jpg

  4. I still remember the day this surfaced last year, and as much as I wanted it for my collection it really is WAY out of my price range. I hoped it would land in a Moore collection and I see it has.

     

    Congratulations Rod on an uber-rare find!

     

    Thanks Kim! I'm very happy to be fortunate enough to get it and to add it the collection.

  5. Excellent pickup - congratulations!

     

    Thanks.

    When I originally found out about this R239c a year ago, I was intrigued to say the least. I knew I would like to have it and tried to make the purchase but the deal did not transpire right away; now a year later I am the proud owner. I am more than happy and this rare and beautiful schützenfest medal is a welcome addition to my collection.

  6. I just acquired the below medal. It is the first example I have seen since I started collecting Swiss shooting medals 30 years ago and is also the first one my Dad has ever seen available in the last 49 years.

     

    The medal is R239c from the 1899 Bern Central Shoot in Langenthal. R239c is a specimen strike and is extremely rare with Richter citing 5 minted but as I alluded to above, there very well could be fewer.

     

    I found out about this beauty about a year ago and just recently finalized its purchase. I'm also happy that it graded as high as it did. When it was first brought to my attention it was raw. In the year since it was graded by NGC as MS65 and that is how I purchased it.

     

    I thought I would share it here with all of you...

     

    b651ff3e.jpg

    00415933.jpg

     

    22cce4cd.jpg

  7. I just received an older Shooting medal from France and thought I would share a few pictures.

     

    39mm

    23.4 g

    Silver

     

    I believe it to be hand made and thus unique. The patina is very nice and I would call it EF+.

     

    It is from a shoot in 1835 in Demigny, Burgundy, France.

     

    It has a rather uniquely styled rim and loop that is thicker than some and the hand engraving is quite intricate.

    cbdde9b9.jpg

    607d34ed.jpg

    b6f7c97b.jpg

    863ee774.jpg

  8. It's scary to see those kind of prices but nice at the same time. :ninja: (website above)

     

    Prices have been going up since the publication of Richters books. Realized and asked prices are consistently matching Richters prices in his set. While this is not that good for buyers it is great for sellers and the hobby as a whole.

     

    I still feel that many medal prices are inflated, especially on the bay but when I see people paying prices that I have never come close to I see that the hobby has moved to the next level and that my collection has increased in value proportionally!

  9. Thanks for the info. Much appreciated.

     

    I'm intrigued by the small medalet being classified as a `jeton'. Why would this have been issued? Who would have been gifted these (or were they sold?). Normally a jeton would be issued on a grace and favour basis to officials or VIP's to mark a event. Is that the case with this one?

     

    Ian

     

    Shooting jetons were the currency of the shoot.

     

    Schützenfest entrants used jetons to pay for - entrance fees, targets, ammunition, food and drinks etc. during the shoot. They would have to purchase jetons from the shooting committee.

     

    Few had face value but most did not. This was so the jetons could be used again at another/next shoot. Perhaps they were worth a franc; however I am unsure of the value of jetons without face value.

     

    There were numerous jetons per shoot including paper jetons of which I have several examples.

  10. As an FYI, the 1840 Solothurn is a jeton rather than a shooting medal. It was not awarded as a shooting prize. It is R434d, I believe it is the 'd' variety, 23mm and 4.3 grams. It is considered to have a rarity of R according to Richter. I too have this jeton and it is one of my favorites! I also have the 1949 medal, I appreciate the shape and I have several other 1949 Chur pieces.

     

    Latest additions:

     

    980901.jpg

     

    980900.jpg

     

    The first was issued for Chur (1949). The second is really tiny for a shooting medal (23mm) and was issued for the fest at Solothurn in 1840.

  11. My latest acquisition: Graubunder 4 Franken struck for the Federal Shooting festival at Chur in 1842.

     

    Would appreciate any info regarding the correct weight of this item so i can satisfy myself as to its bona fides. i got it rather too cheap. It ticks all the right boxes though with regards to dimension, ring, and surface texture. Edge mark - Eintracht Macht Stark followed by a *.

     

    980510.jpg

     

    Hi Ian,

     

    28.3 grams is the weight although I have no official documentation other than personal experience. Please keep in mind that variants such as planchet and scales can make the weight different than the 28.3 grams stated.

     

    I hope this helps,

     

    Rod

×
×
  • Create New...