Jump to content
CoinPeople.com

jaskel

Members
  • Posts

    29
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by jaskel

  1. Recently came across someone selling a Restrike Copy Of Straits Settlement $1 1909. As I didn't heard of a restrike for 1909, so I become curious and brought it from the person. From the pics, it looks like unc and new like prooflike coins.

    v1_zpsxp4cr2yb.jpg

    But once you got the coin, you see a big different.

    1. Dia. 37.9mm instead of 34mm

    2. weight : 26.66g (for 1903,04 with dia. 37mm, for 34mm should be 20g)

    3. Non magnetic

    What I can said is nowadays, fake coins are making it so real even for the weights and sizes, it's really become worry for the coin collectors on finding a true real coins. As we know Straits Settlements $1 have silver content, so I did a few tests on it and failed the test, that's why I concluded this coin is fake.

    The tests I done are;

    1. Sound test. This coin doesn't give a high and long pitch, it's give those sound like a copper-nickel pitch.

    2. Magnet resistant test. As we know, silver is non magnetic and have some resistant to earth magnet. This held in a 45 degree angle, the earth magnet slide down without any resistant unlike my other silver coins.

     

    I not only brought this coin from him, I also brought a 1904B Straits Settlements coin.

    v2_zps7eerk5lh.jpg

    Amazing looking isn't it?

     

    1. Dia. 37.9mm

    2. Weight : 26.67g

    3. Non magnetic

    4. The artist's initials "DES"

    From the data above, one's will thought this is a real 1904B isn't it?

     

    But after the tests, it also proven is fake. :swearing:

    How amazing that people can fake it so real. Even looking at sidney post on how to identify fake and real 1904 straits settlements coin, I think we coin collectors also need to upgrade ourself to able to detect all those fake coin from real.

  2. Hi Sidney, like to ask your opinion as you are the expert in Straits Settlements coin. Recently I found this 50 cent coin on the observe it show some thread of reeded edges. Is this PMD or PMJ? The shape of it is directly opposite of the ' 0 ' position of the reverse. If is a PMJ, the area there should be compressed isn't it?

     

    Still0096_zpstmw8hcqu.png

  3. 2010 India 2 rupee error/variety coin

     

    I need expertise on this error coin. It is Progressive Indirect Design Transfer (PIDT) or die clash or?

     

    There are "Ghosting" on both sides as shown in the pictures

    feb0849c-4c3c-470b-8f96-ca9eeaec91dd_zps Here you can see the hand, finger and the 2.

     

    a1b60483-e386-46b5-a1ea-8d076b9b9977_zps Here the top have some india wordings and the logo in the middle. This photo doesn't show clearly.

     

    Still0081_zpsp1hzpjm3.png

    As compare with the normal same coin on the right, the rounded edge somehow have a line cut.

     

     

  4. Interesting find indeed.

     

    Well you'll first need to check if the coin is silver or not and there are many method to confirm your find over the net. One common test is the magnet test. If the coin is attracted to strong magnet, then it is not silver and it is a fake.

     

    I see a lot of bums and irregulars on the coin surfaces. That is not a good sign. Genuine coins surfaces should be smooth.

     

    Weight of coin - 13.5g

    Diameter - 31mm

    The coin don't attract to magnet and as for weight and diameter, it should still within range.

  5. Nice double mint find. It can be considered as minor errors.

     

    Crack dies defects are common finds in the 5 cents, especially on the 1910 5 cents coin. They are mainly due to wear and tear from minting. I won't put it errors but rather varieties.

     

    Recently a seller sold me a fake 1903 KGV straits settlement $1. :swearing:

    Still0025_zpsx39cwv1m.png

    Still0026_zpssxadruks.png

  6. Nice double mint find. It can be considered as minor errors.

     

    Crack dies defects are common finds in the 5 cents, especially on the 1910 5 cents coin. They are mainly due to wear and tear from minting. I won't put it errors but rather varieties.

    Thanks Sidney.

     

    I found a lot of crack dies on the 1 cent, 5 cents and 10 cents. Double mint not so much. Recently found a 1981 3.5Claw Canadian minted Australia 20 cents in my loose coins :)

×
×
  • Create New...