Hey there, fellow coin collectors! I’ve recently come across a couple of coins in my collection that have some unfortunate rim damage. A 1943 copper penny and a classic 1921 Morgan dollar are among my favorites, but the wear on the edges is really bothering me. I want to make sure I’m storing them properly to prevent any additional deterioration.
I’ve been doing some research on best practices for coins with damage, and I’ve read conflicting advice. Some say to leave them in their current holders, while others recommend moving them to a more protective environment. I often keep my coins in airtight holders, but I’m worried that moisture or air exposure might be even more harmful to these damaged pieces. Has anyone here found a foolproof method, or does my choice of holders matter?
I’d love to hear how you all store your damaged coins! Do you have any special products or techniques that have worked for you? What about using silica gel packets for moisture control? Let’s share tips and tricks to help each other preserve our cherished collectibles!
Storing damaged coins can be tricky, but there are several methods you can use to minimize deterioration. I’ve been a collector for over 15 years, and managing rim damage has taught me a lot. First, I recommend investing in coin holders that provide adequate protection. While a lot of collectors favor airtight holders, especially for valuable coins, it’s important to monitor the conditions inside.
- Cap and Capsules: Numismatic-grade holders often include Mylar or PVC-free materials that won’t damage your coins.
- Silica Gel Packets: These can be very effective in absorbing moisture. I place them inside my storage boxes to maintain low humidity.
- Acid-Free Materials: Make sure any folders or pages you use are acid-free, as this helps reduce chemical reactions with any coin surface.
Also, be mindful of temperature fluctuations; storing your coins in a stable environment is crucial. For my 1921 Morgan, I’ve used a combination of a high-quality holder and a silica gel packet, and it has made a difference. Hope this helps!
@coinenthusiast2023
5 Likes
Thanks for the detailed advice, @coinexpert101! I never thought about using silica gel packs in my storage. I usually keep my coins in those soft holders, but I worry about them getting scratched. Do you think switching to hard cases would be worth it? Would they protect against scratches or just cause more issues? Any recommendations on brands? 
3 Likes
Great topic! I totally resonate with your concern about storing damaged coins. I have a few myself, including an old Indian Head penny with rim damage. I’ve found that coin flips offer a good balance of protection and visibility. I always look for PCGS recommended flips since they’re made from safe materials. Beyond that, I keep the environment around them controlled with a dehumidifier, especially in summer. Has anyone tried using those vacuum-sealed bags for coins? I’m curious if they work well. Cheers!
4 Likes
I haven’t used vacuum-sealed bags, @coinlover22, but I’ve heard mixed reviews. Some collectors find them too constrictive, as they can trap moisture and lead to damage over time. I prefer hard cases as they offer maximum protection while allowing room for the coin’s surface to breathe. Also, I keep an eye on humidity levels using a hygrometer. A stable environment really does make a difference! 
2 Likes
Wow, these are fantastic tips! @coinexpert101, I’m definitely going to try the silica gel packets. Thanks for all the suggestions, everyone! I think I’ll look into hard cases as well. I appreciate your insights! 
1 Like
I keep it simple with a mix of PVC flips and 2x2 holders. They work fine for my lower-value coins, but I would definitely recommend using the good stuff for more valuable pieces. Just be sure to check for PVC damage occasionally, though. It can sneak up on you! Anyone else ever find their coins in rough shape when using those?
Good point, @pennydude59! I’ve lost a few coins to PVC damage over time. It really is something to look out for. That’s why I made the switch to Mylar holders. They’re a bit more costly, but it’s worth it for the peace of mind. Just sharing my experience for anyone who’s as paranoid as I am! 
2 Likes
I’m a huge fan of coin capsules for both protection and visibility. They look great and keep your coins safe. I also keep a stash of those little silica gel packets, @coinenthusiast2023—great idea! Have you checked your local hobby shops? They sometimes have great deals on coin supplies, too. What do you all think about using acid-free boxes as a further protective layer?
1 Like
Thanks for the suggestion, @silverstacker37! I haven’t tried acid-free boxes yet, but I’m going to look into that for sure. The protection they offer sounds valuable, especially for my more delicate coins. Appreciate all you guys sharing your experiences! 
Just a quick follow-up, I’ve been experimenting with anti-tarnish strips inside my storage boxes too. They’ve worked wonders in preventing further oxidation on my silver coins. Anyone else tried these? They really do seem to prolong my collection’s life. @coinenthusiast2023, I’d love to hear how your coins fare after you implement some of these tips. Keep us updated! 
1 Like