Hey fellow collectors! I recently came across a beautiful 1986 Silver Eagle in my collection, but I couldn’t help but notice some pesky milk spots starting to develop. I’ve read about various methods to prevent this from happening, but it’s hard to know which ones actually work. Given how I prize this coin, I want to ensure it stays in pristine condition.
My research so far has led me to different storage options, like using acid-free holders and keeping coins in a stable environment away from humidity. However, I wonder how effective each of these methods really is. I’ve also noticed that coins that have spent time in capsule holders seem to fare better than those in flips. Is there an ideal climate control setup that you all use?
I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences! What techniques have you found most effective in preventing milk spots? Have you dealt with successfully removing them? Let’s share tips and tricks to keep our collections looking their best!
Great topic, CoinEnthusiast87! Preventing milk spots is definitely a concern for all silver coin collectors! In my experience, the environment plays a huge role. I store my coins in a climate-controlled room, keeping the humidity below 40%. Here are some tips I’ve gathered over the years:
Use acid-free holders or capsules. They protect against environmental damage.Avoid touching the surface of the coins; use gloves if you need to handle them.Keep your coins out of direct sunlight to prevent oxidation.Consider silica gel packs in your storage area to absorb excess moisture. I once had a few coins with milk spots due to poor storage, and switching to capsules really made a difference. I’ve seen some good results from brands like Airtite and BCW. How about everyone else? What are you using?
5 Likes
I’ve heard good things about using 2x2 holders vs. flips! How do they compare when it comes to long-term preservation?
3 Likes
That’s a great question, @CoinNovice88! From what I’ve gathered, 2x2 holders are definitely better in preventing milk spots, as they use non-reactive materials. Flips can sometimes trap moisture, which might contribute to spotting. What do others think?
4 Likes
Definitely agree with you, @SilverSleuth! A stable humidity level is crucial. I keep a hygrometer in my safe to monitor conditions. I also add anti-tarnish strips to my storage bags—anyone else tried those? I have noticed a considerable difference in keeping my coins pristine. There was a marked decrease in tarnishing since I started using them!
2 Likes
I have a small dehumidifier in my coin room, and it does the trick. Just make sure to empty it frequently to keep the levels low. If you’re looking for products, I found this great PCGS article on humidity control for collectors. It really helped me set things up. What about cleaning methods for milk spots—anyone had success with that?
2 Likes
I once had milk spots on an MS-70 coin—it was heartbreaking. I read somewhere that a common mistake is using the wrong type of cleaning solution. I’ve actually been using a gentle soap and rinse with distilled water. Though it’s not a guarantee, it worked for me! Just don’t scrub too hard!
3 Likes
Thanks for sharing your experience, @NumismaticNerd! Cleaning can really be a challenge. Have you had any luck with ultrasonic cleaners, or do you stick to hand cleaning?
1 Like
Haha, funny story, I had a box of coins in the basement that developed some serious milk spots due to humidity—never thought I’d use a dehumidifier for coins! Glad I found this forum to learn from you all. Now, I’m wanting to upgrade my storage to an air-tight safe. Any recommendations?
2 Likes
@GoldDigger45, I recently bought a Stack-On safe, and it’s been amazing! If you’re looking for something more specialized, check out USMint for some secure options that won’t break the bank.
3 Likes
Milk spots can be such a pain! I’ve been using coin capsules, and they seem to protect my Silver Eagles quite well, especially when paired with a cool storage environment. Also, I always take care to place my coins in a separate box, lined with felt. It adds another layer of protection. Anyone else tried that?
2 Likes
@GrandmaCoin, I love the felt lining idea! I think I’ll implement that too. 
It seems like such a simple yet effective change. Also, I always ensure to keep my coins in a well-ventilated area to avoid moisture buildup. What do you think about the market for graded coins? Could they be more prone to milk spots if not stored properly?
2 Likes