Hey fellow collectors! I recently stumbled upon the D over S mint mark error and it’s got me really intrigued. As someone who’s just starting to dip their toes into the world of error coins, I can’t help but wonder what makes this particular error so special. I found a 1916-D Walking Liberty half dollar in my local shop that had this D over S mint mark, and I couldn’t resist picking it up.
After doing some research, I learned that the D over S mint mark error happened because the Denver Mint accidentally used a San Francisco die, which is a fascinating little piece of history! I noticed that the coin is in pretty decent condition, maybe Fine to Very Fine. But I’m curious – how much does the condition really affect its value? I’ve seen prices range significantly, depending on the source.
What are your thoughts on this error? Have any of you got a D over S that you cherish? I’d love to hear about how you determine its value or any tips on spotting similar errors in the wild!
The D over S mint mark error is fascinating for several reasons! First, it’s a prime example of how minting processes can sometimes lead to unexpected outcomes. This error occurred in 1916 when the Denver Mint used a die that was initially prepared for the San Francisco Mint. Because of this mix-up, coins struck during this period bore both mint marks – the D over the S.
As for the value, it heavily depends on the coin’s condition. In a well-preserved state, prices can soar, going well over a thousand dollars! Here’s a general grading scale to keep in mind:
- Fine (F): $300-$500
- Very Fine (VF): $500-$800
- Mint State (MS): Upwards of $2000!
Ultimately, the demand for this error coin keeps it on collectors’ radars. Congratulations on spotting one; I’m sure it’s a great addition to your collection!
Check this for more details on its rarity.
5 Likes
Thank you, @CoinExpert99, for the detailed breakdown! That value range really helps put things into perspective. Do the values differ based on where you sell or appraise them? I want to ensure I’m not missing out on potential gains!
2 Likes
Hey @CoinCollector42! I’ve had good luck selling mine at local coin shows. I find that in-person transactions can sometimes fetch better prices. Plus, meeting fellow collectors is a bonus! Condition is so critical; buyers look for clear details, and a poor grade can drop the value quickly.
3 Likes
Another angle to consider is the historical significance! The 1916-D is not only popular for its mint mark error but also because it marked the start of the Walking Liberty series, which is beloved by many collectors. Its design is iconic, and finding one with that error makes it a real keeper. If you are ever in the market to sell, I’d recommend using NGC for grading—helps substantiate your asking price as they have a strong reputation!
4 Likes
Haha, I always joke that finding a D over S is like finding a unicorn! 
I haven’t come across one, but it’s definitely on my wish list now. If you figure out how to spot these errors, you’ll have to share your secrets!
1 Like
@CoinCollector42, values can vary quite a bit! Places like eBay might give you a lower return due to fees. However, high-end auction houses specialize in such items and often yield better prices due to their vast collector networks. Just be sure to factor in shipping and selling fees.
2 Likes
I got lucky and found a D over S Walking Liberty in terrible shape, but at least I could confirm it was an error! Even in lower grades, these coins can sometimes sell for $200 or more. Just make sure to keep it safe; I’ve heard of too many collectors losing theirs due to mishandling! Condition really matters!
2 Likes
So true, @EagleEyeSam! I’ve seen some collectors lose value just by how they store the coins. Laser focus on environment is key. I prefer using archival quality holders. Has anyone else had experience with different storage options?
3 Likes
Speaking of value, don’t forget grading! If you think yours might be close to an MS grade, consider getting it graded. The difference in price can be astonishing. Trust me; I once found a coin marked as VF but graded MS later, turning a $300 win into a $1200 find!
5 Likes
Thanks, @CoinHunterJoe! Your story encourages me to get it graded! I suppose even if it ends up around the $200 mark due to condition, the fact that I found it makes it special to me. I love hearing everyone’s insights and experiences!
4 Likes