Hey fellow collectors! I recently dove into the world of W quarters, specifically the 2019 and 2020 issues, and I’m fascinated by the nuances of grading them. However, as a beginner, I find myself a bit overwhelmed with the various grading scales (from AG to MS) and how subtle differences in condition can drastically affect their value.
I’ve spent some time researching online, and I’ve come across some great resources, but I’m still unsure how to visually assess coin conditions without making rookie mistakes. For instance, I’ve noticed some of the quarters in my collection have light scratches or spots that I’m not sure affect the grade significantly. What are some key indicators to look for that might help me differentiate between an MS63 and an MS67?
I’d love to hear from those with more experience—what do you consider when grading W quarters? Any tips on specific tools to use or mistakes to avoid? Let’s share some insights and help each other refine our grading skills!
Welcome to the world of W quarters! Grading can indeed be daunting, especially if you’re just starting out. Here are a few tips I’ve gathered over the years:
- Always use a magnifying glass (at least 10x) to inspect the coin for fine details.
- Familiarize yourself with the grading scale—know the differences between AU and MS grades.
- Pay attention to the luster of the coin; a mirror-like shine usually indicates a higher grade.
I recommend checking out sites like
PCGS or
NGC for comprehensive guides on grading. Happy collecting!
12 Likes
Thanks for the tips, @CoinGuru73! I’ll definitely check out the PCGS and NGC sites for more detailed info. What specifics should I look for in terms of scratches or spots on the quarters? Are there certain types that can be overlooked?
5 Likes
I totally get you, @CoinEnthusiast42! When I started, I was confused by the grading scales too. One big thing is to look at the edges of the coins. If they have any wear or nicks, that can drastically lower the grade. Also, don’t forget about strike quality. If parts of the design are weakly struck, that’s a telltale sign as well. Just keep practicing, and you’ll improve! 
8 Likes
Great point about the edges, @SilverHunter88! I hadn’t thought about how important that detail is. Do you have a favorite tool you use when evaluating your coins?
4 Likes
As a long-time collector of W quarters, I can share that lighting is also crucial. Use natural light or a high-quality lamp to analyze the coin. This helps you spot any hairlines or marks that might not be visible under poor lighting. And don’t be afraid to ask for a second opinion from fellow collectors—another set of eyes can catch what you may miss! Happy hunting!
10 Likes
Thanks for the lighting tip, @NumisNerd1! I appreciate everyone’s input. It really helps to hear firsthand experiences. How do you all feel about using price guides for determining values? Are they reliable?
3 Likes
Price guides can be a good starting point, but always take them with a grain of salt. I usually compare them with auction prices to get a better sense of value. Sites like USMint also provide up-to-date info on recent releases and sales that might influence value. Just remember that market demand can change rapidly.
6 Likes
You know, sometimes you find a hidden gem in circulation! I once found a 2020 W quarter with a small minting error—couldn’t believe my luck! 
Always keep an eye on your change!
7 Likes
Wow, @WQtrCollector22! That’s awesome! I’m not sure I’ve come across anything like that before. Any advice on how to spot those minting errors when going through my coins?
2 Likes
Sure thing! Look for things like double strikes, off-center strikes, and die cracks. They can sometimes be subtle, so using good lighting and a magnifying glass really helps. Plus, there are great guides on sites like NGC that show common errors for W quarters. Keep at it! 
5 Likes