Hey fellow collectors! I’m pretty excited because I’m finally looking to purchase my first uncirculated Fraser Buffalo. I’ve always been drawn to the intricate design and historical significance of these coins, and I can’t wait to add one to my collection.
I’ve done a bit of research, but I feel a bit overwhelmed by the price variations I’m seeing out there. From what I gather, uncirculated examples can range from around $20 to over $100 depending on the mint condition and whether there’s any special feature, but I’d love to hear your thoughts. Have you recently bought one or seen any good deals? What factors do you think really impact the price?
I’ve been particularly curious about the specifics of the coin condition. How do you all assess whether a coin is truly uncirculated? And do you think buying from a reputable dealer is the best route, or are there any risks I should be aware of when purchasing online? Looking forward to your insights!
Welcome to the world of coin collecting! The Fraser Buffalo is a great choice! Based on my experience, uncirculated specimens typically range from $25 to $150 depending on their condition. The key factors affecting the price include the mint mark, overall grade, and if it’s been graded by a reputable service like PCGS or NGC. I personally bought one for $80 last month from a local dealer who had the coin graded. It had an incredible shine and no visible wear. Make sure to ask the seller about the history of the coin too; some of them can come with interesting stories!
1 Like
Thanks for the detailed info, @BuffaloBill98! 
It sounds like a $25-$150 range is reasonable. I’m a bit nervous about detailed assessments of the coin’s condition. How can I tell if it’s genuinely uncirculated?
2 Likes
Great question, @CoinExplorer92! When assessing whether a coin is truly uncirculated, look for these tells:
- It should have no signs of wear on the raised surfaces,
- There should be no scratches or distracting blemishes,
- The luster should be bright and reflect light well.
I always opt for coins that have been graded by PCGS or NGC for peace of mind. Happy hunting!
3 Likes
If you’re still unsure about condition, I recommend watching some grading videos on YouTube. Learning to grade yourself is invaluable! I’ve found a few that explain the difference between uncirculated and typical circulated coins really well. 
Let me know if you want some links!
3 Likes
Hey everyone! I just snagged an uncirculated Fraser Buffalo for $70, and I’m super happy with it! I agree with what’s been said here about the grading. Condition is everything, and I always check for the shine and details before buying. Buying from a reputable dealer is a must, especially online since the risk of counterfeits can be higher. Just be careful and trust your instincts when it comes to sellers. Good luck, @CoinExplorer92! You’ll love it once you get it! 
6 Likes
That’s great to hear, @CoinGeek92! It’s fun to see them in your hand when they arrive in the mail. Don’t forget, if you find a good local coin shop, it’s worth stopping by for a look! You can often get better deals and check the coins in person! Plus, you might learn something new from the owner! 
2 Likes
I think $50-$125 is a fair range for uncirculated Fraser Buffalos. Just keep an eye on any recent sales in marketplaces or certain online auctions. The prices tend to fluctuate a lot, especially closer to show seasons. If you ever go to coin shows, you might find great deals as well. Looking forward to hearing about your purchase, @CoinExplorer92! 
4 Likes
Thanks for the insight, @CoinCollectorChris! I hadn’t considered how coin shows might affect prices. I’ll keep that in mind for my search. Have you been to many shows? What’s been your best find? 
2 Likes
Oh, definitely, @CoinExplorer92! My best find was a very rare die variety of the Buffalo that I got for under $200! Keep your eyes open at shows, because you can find coins that may not be listed online! There’s a whole community vibe at these events, and they’re a lot of fun. Can’t wait to see what you end up with!
3 Likes