Hey fellow collectors! Recently, I acquired a 1955 doubled die obverse Lincoln penny (DDO) that I’ve been studying. It’s such a fascinating piece of American numismatics, and I’m thrilled to have it in my collection. However, I’m a bit uncertain about how to accurately assess its condition.
I’ve done some research and learned that the DDO can be graded from Good (G) to Mint State (MS), but I’m curious about others’ experiences with grading this specific coin. My example has some wear on Lincoln’s cheek and the date, but the doubling is quite pronounced when viewed under magnification. I’m torn between thinking it’s a Fine (F) or maybe even an Extremely Fine (EF)! Has anyone had similar grading dilemmas with this coin?
I’d love to hear your thoughts and any tips you might have on assessing the condition of the 1955 DDO. What do you look for? Do you have any resources to recommend for understanding the grading nuances? Thanks in advance for your help!
The grading of the 1955 DDO is definitely a nuanced topic, especially since it incorporates both the surface wear and the prominence of the doubling. Your observation about Lincoln’s cheek and the date is crucial. Typically, a coin in Fine (F) condition will show moderate wear, with major features clearly visible but lacking detail in high points. On the other hand, an Extremely Fine (EF) example will have only minor wear, retaining much of its original detail, particularly in the areas most susceptible to wear.
Here’s what I suggest for your assessment:
- Use a jewelers loupe to closely inspect the doubling; see how defined it is against the background.
- Look for any distracting marks or discoloration that could affect the overall grade.
- Consider using grading guides from reputable sources like PCGS or NGC to compare images and descriptions.
It can be helpful to compare your coin against other examples from those databases. Good luck, and feel free to share some pictures if you can! I’d love to take a look!
5 Likes
I totally empathize with your grading dilemma! I went through the same trouble with my 1955 DDO. I ended up sending mine to be graded, and it came back as AU (About Uncirculated), which surprised me because I thought it was more of an EF. It’s all about the details and the absence of significant wear. @coinenthusiast92, have you considered getting professional grading? It can help settle any doubts you might have! Plus, it adds value. Just a thought! 
3 Likes
Thanks @numismatist_guru for the thorough breakdown! I’ll definitely take those tips into account, especially about using the loupe. I’ve checked out PCGS before, and it’s super helpful. I’m probably leaning towards getting it graded as well @rarefinds81, but I want to make sure I’m confident in my assessment first. I’ll share a picture soon! 
2 Likes
@rarefinds81 I get where you’re coming from! I once thought I had a solid EF, but after grading, it came out as just an F because of some hidden scratches. It can be a real rollercoaster! @coinenthusiast92, make sure to take a good look under different lighting; it can reveal potential flaws you might miss otherwise.
4 Likes
Don’t stress too much over the grading! It’s all part of the fun in collecting! 
I think as long as you love the coin and appreciate its history, you’re in a good spot. Just remember that grading can be subjective sometimes!
1 Like
Grading the 1955 DDO can be especially tricky due to the various characteristics of the doubling. Bring a few MS and AU coins of other types to compare while you’re assessing yours. Generally, the doubling should be examined under good lighting; sometimes, minor imperfections that can’t be spotted under typical conditions jump out under scrutiny. Here are some additional resources you might want to look into:
Looking forward to what you find!
6 Likes
Yep, grading is definitely subjective. I’ve had coins I felt were worth at least AU, and they came back as F from grading companies. Ridiculous sometimes! @coin_addict89 is right—enjoy the collecting journey rather than stressing over grades. They’re just labels at the end of the day! 
2 Likes
I completely agree with @expertcoins! Lighting can be the game-changer in assessing your coin’s condition. I had a similar experience assessing a 1955 DDO, and changing the angle of the light revealed some flaws that I hadn’t noticed before. It’s great to see this discussion going on! Keep it up, guys!
3 Likes
Totally with you, @coin_addict89! At the end of the day, it’s about collecting what you love. Grades may help with value, but the stories behind each coin are what matter most to me! Plus, cracked grades can still be equally beautiful in their unique way! 
1 Like
It’s true! There’s a kind of charm to those lower-graded coins. I always say they have ‘character’! 
You can learn so much just by observing the wear. I’d love to see everyone’s finds!
1 Like