Hey everyone! As a new collector, I recently picked up a few older coins that have seen better days. One in particular, a 1913 Buffalo Nickel, has quite a bit of tarnish, and I find myself torn about whether to clean it or leave it as is. I’ve done some research and found all sorts of opinions on the matter. Of course, I know that cleaning can devalue coins, but some collectors swear by certain methods.
So here’s my main question: what are your best practices when it comes to cleaning collectible coins? I’ve read about using distilled water and soft brushes, but I’m wary of anything that might scratch the surface. I’ve even come across more aggressive methods like using baking soda, but I’m not sure I want to take that risk.
I’d love to hear your experiences! What have you tried that worked, and what methods have you avoided because they seemed too risky? Let’s share our collective wisdom on preserving our treasures without ruining them!
Cleaning coins is a delicate issue! As a collector for over 15 years, I’ve seen my fair share of tarnished coins and the impacts of aggressive cleaning methods. Personally, I always recommend soaking the coin in distilled water for 24 hours. This can help remove dirt without scratching the surface. Here’s a simple method I’ve used successfully:
- Soak the coin for 24 hours.
- Use a soft, lint-free cloth to gently pat it dry.
- If necessary, repeat the process rather than using a brush or any abrasive materials.
It’s critical to avoid anything abrasive, including baking soda. Using it might initially seem effective, but it can leave micro-scratches that severely reduce the value of the coin. Just a tip: the less you do, the better!
What has your experience been like with the Buffalo Nickel,
@CoinEnthusiast77?
10 Likes
Thanks for the advice, @CoinMaster92! I appreciate your detailed method. I did soak my Buffalo Nickel last night, and I think it’s already looking a bit better. I’ll let it air dry and see how it goes! I’ll definitely avoid those harsher methods now. Have you ever had to deal with any significant tarnishing that required more than just soaking?
4 Likes
Definitely avoid cleaning coins whenever possible! I’ve been in this hobby for over two decades, and I can tell you that untouched coins often maintain their value much better than those that have been cleaned. I usually only rinse with distilled water and leave it at that. @CoinEnthusiast77, I highly advise against anything like baking soda. It’s tempting, but it can be detrimental!
Pro tip: if you’re trying to get rid of more stubborn tarnish, consider sending it to a professional instead. It may seem costly, but preserving the coin’s value is worth it!
7 Likes
@CoinEnthusiast77, it sounds like you’re on the right track! Remember that patience is key. As for cleaning, I once mistakenly used a soft brush on a coin I thought was tarnished, only to realize later it was just dirt. I ended up scratching it quite a bit. Now, I only use my fingers to gently wipe the edges after soaking. It’s much safer!
6 Likes
If you’re really stuck on a specific piece, consider buying a coin preservation kit. They are specially designed to safely clean coins without causing damage. I’ve utilized one before, and it works wonders! Just make sure to read through the instructions carefully. You don’t want to make things worse! Also, I agree with what @OldCoinGuy said—sometimes it’s better to leave it be.
9 Likes
Those are some great suggestions, everyone! I’m going to take @RareCoinHunter’s advice and look into some preservation kits. I’ve been wary of the DIY methods, especially with my Buffalo Nickel. Just to clarify, are there any particular brands you guys recommend?
4 Likes
I’ve had luck with the J. D. McCaw Coin Care products. They’re simple to use and really effective. Just remember to follow the instructions for best results! @CoinEnthusiast77, when I used them on a 1956 Rosie, it brought back some shine without any scratches. Good luck with your cleaning!
3 Likes
Quick tip! If you’re unsure about cleaning, just don’t do it! I often find that newer collectors get overly anxious about tarnish when sometimes the best thing is just to let it be. That natural patina can add character and tell the coin’s history. @CoinEnthusiast77, if your Buffalo Nickel was a family heirloom, it might be worth considering keeping it as is!
5 Likes
Cleaning coins can be a tricky business! I once used vinegar on a set of old pennies thinking it would help—let’s just say that did NOT end well! Now I strictly stick to distilled water and soft cloths. So many collectors have made that mistake, but it’s a lesson learned. Also, on the topic of baking soda, I completely agree with @OldCoinGuy; it’s not worth the risk at all! They say, ‘patina is a collector’s friend,’ so embrace the history!
8 Likes