Hey fellow collectors! I’ve recently been diving into the deep end of my collection, and I stumbled upon a couple of rare varieties that have really sparked my interest. Last week, I found a 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln penny at a local coin show, and let me tell you, the condition is remarkable for its age—maybe an XF40! It’s got that beautiful, rich color that I absolutely adore, and it’s been a real thrill to add it to my collection.
That got me wondering, what are some of the rarest varieties you have come across in your own hunts? I’ve heard whispers about the 1913 Liberty Head nickel and the 1894-S Barber dime, but I’m curious to know what else is out there. I’ve read some insights on grading and market trends, but I’d love to hear your personal stories! What’s the rarest coin you’ve added to your collection, and what was the hunting process like?
Looking forward to reading your stories, and perhaps we can get into some discussions about how these rare finds shape our collections. Have you come across any surprising finds lately? How do you highlight these unique coins in your displays? Can’t wait to hear your thoughts!
That 1909-S V.D.B. penny sounds amazing! I found a 1937-D three-legged buffalo nickel at an estate sale a few months ago. When I spotted it, I thought it was a joke. The owner didn’t even realize what they had! The coin was identified in an AG3 condition, but it was a thrill to add such a rare piece to my collection. I love how you can find hidden treasures in the most unexpected places. I also heard about that 1913 Liberty Head nickel - absolutely mind-blowing what some of those can fetch at auction. Have you thought about getting your penny graded?
5 Likes
I was lucky enough to come across a 1916-D Mercury dime last summer at a flea market. The owner didn’t even recognize its value! I ended up paying $15 for it. It’s currently sitting in my display case, and I often get asked about it when friends visit. Although it’s only in an F12 grade, it still gets a lot of compliments. The thrill of that find is still fresh in my memory. What do you all think about the value of coins that are in lower grades compared to higher ones?
7 Likes
Wow, @SilverSeeker, a 1916-D Mercury dime for $15? That’s incredible! It really shows that you can find amazing things in the most unexpected places. I think lower-grade coins can still hold significant value to collectors, especially if they’re rare. They often tell a story. What condition is yours in? Any plans to get it graded?
3 Likes
The 1937-D three-legged buffalo is definitely a highlight for many collectors! I remember my first time seeing one at a coin show. There’s just something special about discovering pieces like that! In my collection, a standout is my 1804 silver dollar—though it’s a replica. Still, the history and lore behind it are fascinating. True 1804 dollars are among the rarest in existence. Also, getting to share the journey of finding coins adds so much more value to them. Have you used any online resources for your coin hunting, like PCGS or NGC?
3 Likes
I recently found a 1955 double die Lincoln penny while checking through rolls at the bank! I thought it was just another penny at first, but when I noticed the doubling in ‘In God We Trust’, my heart skipped a beat. I sent it for grading, and it came back as AU58. It’s a keeper in my book! Has anyone else discovered errors or varieties while going through loose change?
6 Likes
That’s awesome, @QuirkyCollector! Finding a Double Die is a thrill for sure! A couple of years ago, I found a 1983 copper penny in my change! I had to double-check my reference guides because the odds of finding one are just insane. It’s a MS63, and I can hardly believe my luck. Coin roll hunting can really surprise you sometimes! What’s been the most surprising find in your collections?
8 Likes
Two amazing finds in one thread! This is why I love coin collecting. @CoinDetective, that 1983 copper penny is a legendary find! I keep hearing about these error coins, but I haven’t come across any myself yet. Maybe I should start checking more rolls. Any tips on where to look or what to look for?
2 Likes
What a thrilling discussion! I’ve been collecting rare coins for over 15 years now and have had some luck finding uncommon pieces. My prized possession is a 1907 Indian Head penny in MS66 condition that I found at a local antique shop. The dealer had mispriced it, and I couldn’t believe my eyes. It’s amazing how much potential there is in local shops. Don’t overlook them! Condition is vital for determining value, so I always check before I buy. What’s the craziest deal you’ve scored at a shop?
9 Likes
Great topic, @CoinNerd92. One of the rarest coins I’ve come across is a 1901-S barber quarter in G4 condition that was part of my late uncle’s collection. The sentimental value makes it stand out even more for me. It’s fascinating to see how the history of these coins intertwines with our personal stories. Have you guys ever inherited any coins that made you rethink their worth in your collection?
5 Likes
@DaveTheGrader, recently I inherited a 1942 Walking Liberty half dollar from my grandfather’s collection! It was in surprisingly good condition, almost VF20, and I treasure it even more because of the memories attached to it. It’s really amazing how coins can connect us to our pasts. Have you had a chance to research its value? Any ideas on how to display it for maximum impact?
4 Likes
Great to hear about your grandfather’s coin, @CoinCollector88! Walking Liberty half dollars have such a beautiful design! I’d recommend checking sites like the US Mint to see the historical context for your coin and maybe get some pricing references. As for display, a nice shadow box could really highlight its history! What was your grandfather’s favorite way to share his collection?
3 Likes