Hey fellow collectors! I’ve been toying with the idea of trading a few coins from my collection lately. I have some nice pieces graded by both PCGS and NGC, and I’m really curious about which grading service might make it easier to sell in today’s market. Personally, I’ve found that my PCGS graded coins tend to get more attention, but I’m wondering if that’s just my experience or if it holds true for others as well.
In my research, I’ve noticed that PCGS has a strong reputation, and their holders seem to attract buyers quickly. However, I have a couple of NGC pieces that are just stunning, and I believe their quality is on par with PCGS. I’m stuck! Is it just about brand loyalty, or do you think one service offers better resale potential in our current climate?
What do you all think? Have you had more success selling coins from one grading service over the other? I’d love to hear about your experiences and insights. Any personal anecdotes about flips or trades, and maybe advice on which direction I should lean towards would be greatly appreciated!
Great topic, CoinEnthusiast87! I’ve bought and sold a fair number of coins graded by both PCGS and NGC, and my experience has shown that, while both companies have excellent reputations, there are definitely trends in the market. Generally speaking, I find that coins graded by PCGS tend to sell faster—perhaps due to their marketing and the number of collectors who trust their grading standards more. However, NGC has been gaining ground lately, especially with certain series like modern bullion coins. It’s really about the specific coin you have and its demand. If you have unique or high-demand coins from NGC, those can move just as quickly. In the end, it’s wise to do some research on the specific coins and see which grading company they are associated with. Also, check recent auction results for similar coins to get a better gauge. Happy collecting!
5 Likes
Thanks for your insights, @CoinMaster99! I do have some unique coins that I think are high quality. I appreciate your advice on checking auction results!
2 Likes
Personal experience: I have sold more NGC coins at shows than PCGS, mostly because the buyers were looking for specific series. I think it also depends on the collectors attending those shows. Some collectors are just NGC loyalists! If you’re trading online, @CoinMaster99 has a point that PCGS coins might sell faster. But don’t underestimate the NGC base! Keep an eye on the trends, and maybe you’ll find a good market for your NGC coins when selling. Good luck!
3 Likes
I agree with @NumismaticNerd. I once had a rare NGC piece that surprised me in how quickly it sold! Sometimes it’s about the rarity and the demand rather than the grading service. Just my two cents!
1 Like
I think the market is very much opinion-based. Personally, I find that PCGS coins are seen as more desirable, especially for investment purposes. However, NGC has great customer service, and their holders look nice! I’d suggest getting opinions from potential buyers if you can. Maybe create a poll to see what your friends would prefer!
Honestly, I’ve seen some incredible NGC coins sell for close to what PCGS graded coins go for. Sometimes, it’s just about the presentation. If your NGC coins are in pristine condition (like MS-66 or better), you should have no issues selling. It may even help to get them re-evaluated by PCGS if you’re really stuck between services. Just remember, a coin is worth what someone is willing to pay!
4 Likes
Thanks for your perspective, @OldFartCoiner! I had considered getting a couple evaluated again, but I wasn’t sure if it was worth the extra cost. Your thoughts help cement that idea!
1 Like
@SilverSeeker, that’s a clever idea! A poll could really give you a sense of which way to lean when trading. Besides that, don’t forget to consider who you’re trading with. Some collectors just prefer one grading service over the other!
2 Likes
I’ve noticed that forums like this are invaluable for gauging market sentiment. Just last week I traded an NGC coin that was in high MS condition for a rare PCGS piece, and I couldn’t be happier! Keep interacting like this; you’ll get great advice. Good luck!
3 Likes
Why did the coin collector take up gardening? Because he wanted to grow his ‘mint’! 
But seriously, it’s important to remember that both grading services have their strengths. Happy collecting!
5 Likes