Hey fellow collectors! I’ve been diving deep into my Mercury Dime collection lately, and I’ve come to a crossroads regarding where to put my investment dollars next. I have a few pieces in VF and EF conditions, but I’ve also been eyeing some rarer dates that haven’t hit my collection yet.
I’m curious to know your thoughts on whether focusing on higher grades for the FB (Full Bands) Mercurys might yield better long-term returns compared to snatching up those more elusive dates that lack the same grade. I’ve done a bit of research and noticed that while the higher graded coins often command premium prices, the rare dates tend to appreciate over time just due to their scarcity.
What has your experience been? Have you had better luck with higher grades in the long run, or do those rare dates steal the show? I’m eager to hear your insights and perhaps even your favorite pieces from both categories. Let’s get this discussion rolling!
Great question, CoinEnthusiast88! When it comes to investing in Mercury Dimes, I’ve found that it largely depends on your collecting goals. If you’re aiming for long-term appreciation, I would advocate for focusing on rare dates first.
- They are often more sought after by collectors.
- Scarcity can drive their prices up significantly compared to more common dated coins.
I’ve personally had some success with rare dates like the 1916-D, which really appreciate over time. That said,
Full Bands coins can hold their value well, especially in higher grades, but the market can fluctuate more with these. It’s always a balancing act! Also, consider your budget—higher grades can get pricey quickly. What pieces do you currently own that you’re considering? Would love to know!
@CoinEnthusiast88
5 Likes
Thanks for your insights, @SilverSeeker! I do have a few common dates in EF and VF grades, but I’m eyeing some 1921 and 1942-D pieces that are in lower grades. Sounds like I should prioritize rarity. What do you think about the condition of a rare coin affecting its value?
2 Likes
Investing in the right areas can be tricky! I’ve been collecting for over a decade, and here’s my take:
- Higher grade FB Mercurys tend to attract a more niche market.
- In contrast, rarer dates, even in lower grades, can fetch higher prices over time due to consistent demand.
It really comes down to market trends—keeping an eye on auction results and forums can give you the edge. If you plan to diversify, perhaps split your investment between both categories? Also, don’t forget to check out resources like
PCGS for valuation insights!
@CoinEnthusiast88
4 Likes
Condition plays a huge role! While rarity is vital, a G4 on a rare date won’t typically outvalue an AU50 common coin. For instance, I once sold a 1945 Mercury that was MS65 and made a killing! But a 1931-D I bought in VG8 didn’t appreciate as expected despite its rarity. To summarize, aim for higher grade rarities if your budget allows it!
3 Likes
I would lean towards investing in those rare dates! Like @RareCoinHunter mentioned, scarcity often drives the market. Also, it’s sometimes easier to find buyers for a rare coin compared to a higher-grade common one during downturns. Plus, they make for great conversation pieces! Nothing beats revealing a rare find to fellow collectors!
6 Likes
@RareCoinHunter, your point about market trends is spot on! I read a great article on NGC recently about how certain years see spikes in interest for rare dates. It’s always best to stay informed. Also, building relationships in the community can pay off when it comes to rare finds! Anyone here have a favorite Mercury Dime story?
2 Likes
Honestly, I think you can’t go wrong with either route! A well-rounded collection should have both rare dates and high grades for investment diversity. Just be wary of what you buy—always check for authenticity! By the way, @CoinGuy42, I agree—those rare finds do spark wonderful conversations! 
3 Likes
You all have given me so much to think about. I definitely want my collection to have a balance. I’ll keep my eyes peeled for those rare dates! Thanks again, everyone, your advice is invaluable!
3 Likes
Couldn’t agree more, @DimeDude! I’ve consistently found that having a diverse collection not only provides better investment opportunities but also keeps the joy of collecting alive. A good mix is essential. Who knows, you might stumble onto a rare piece while looking for high grades!
2 Likes