Hey fellow collectors! I recently dove into the world of VDB pennies, and I’m hooked! I started with a few common dates, but now I’m wondering if I should focus more on rarer coins. The thrill of finding an 1909-S V.D.B. or even a 1910 is exciting, but my budget keeps reminding me that common dates like the 1911 or 1912 might make my collection look fuller in comparison.
I’ve done a bit of research and found that many collectors recommend starting with the common dates to build up a foundation. This way, I can learn more about grading and the market before shelling out big bucks for rarities. However, I can’t help but feel tempted by those rare pieces! I’d love to hear how others balance building their collections. Do you stick primarily with common dates until you feel secure in your collecting habits, or do you dive headfirst into the rare stuff even early on?
So, what strategies do you all use? Have you had success focusing either on common or rare dates? Any tips on how to assess the condition and make those key acquisitions would be greatly appreciated!
Welcome to the world of VDB pennies! It’s an exciting journey. I started with common dates too—mainly the 1911 and 1912. They’re great for learning about grading because they are more affordable. Once I felt comfortable, I slowly transitioned to rare coins like the 1909-S V.D.B. It’s a solid strategy to develop your skills first. Keep track of grading standards and don’t rush into large investments until you’re confident.
- Start with coin shows or online auctions.
- Ask questions to experienced collectors.
- Join local clubs for advice and networking.
I still fondly remember my first rare find—it was exhilarating! Best of luck!
5 Likes
Great advice, CoinMaster78! I too started with common dates. As I built confidence, I gradually set aside a little more for rarer finds. The 1909-S V.D.B. is definitely a grail for many—but you don’t have to rush into that. Setting milestones for yourself, like purchasing a specific number of common dates before moving on to rarities, can be helpful.
3 Likes
Thanks for the input so far! I really appreciate the advice. I think I’m leaning towards starting with the common dates to get a feel for grading and pricing before going for the rarities. Any specific tips on where to buy VDBs? Are there online stores or marketplaces you’d recommend?
2 Likes
Absolutely! Check out NGC and the US Mint for reliable buying options. You can often find auctions on eBay—just ensure the seller has good feedback. Also, joining forums can lead to community sales or trade opportunities, where you might find better deals and trusted members to deal with!
4 Likes
Here’s my two cents: the thrill of pocketing a rare VDB is unmatched! I suggest you balance your collection with both common and a few rare pieces, if possible. You could do a “common first” approach and then set a budget for saving up for those rarities! Plus, don’t forget about condition; a lower-grade rare coin might still be a standout piece.
3 Likes
Rarity vs. commonality is an eternal debate. I started diving straight for the 1909-S V.D.B. but ended up broke! 
Definitely agree with taking it slow and enjoying the journey. I still have my common ones that have great stories behind them!
2 Likes
As someone who has graded a lot of coins, I cannot stress the importance of learning the grading scale. For VDB pennies, knowing whether you’re looking at a Fine or a Mint State can be the difference in price and collection value. I recommend picking up a copy of the “PCGS Grading Guide”. It really helped me! Good luck with your collection!
5 Likes
Haha, @CoinJester! I totally get that! It can be so tempting to dive in. Thanks for the laughter and the advice! I’m leaning towards patience now.
1 Like