Hey fellow collectors! I recently stumbled upon a beautiful 2006 Fraser Buffalo coin at a local coin shop. However, what caught my eye was a noticeable discrepancy in the design—there seems to be an unusual mark in the field beside the buffalo that I’ve never seen before. I’ve done a bit of digging online, but I’m still unsure whether this is a mint error or just some post-mint damage.
I’ve read that the Fraser Buffalo coins can have various errors, but this one looks particularly unique. The coin is graded at around MS-65, with some contact marks but nothing too severe. What’s piqued my interest is how such a pronounced feature can remain unrecognized by the community. Have any of you encountered similar issues with this series? How do you typically go about verifying if it’s a genuine mint error or not?
I’d love to hear your thoughts! What resources or techniques do you find most useful in determining the authenticity of error coins? Also, if you know of any experts or forums where I might get a clearer opinion, I’d really appreciate it. Thanks in advance for your insights!
Hey @CoinExplorer88! It sounds like you’ve found a really interesting coin! The Fraser Buffalo series does have some notable mint errors, like die breaks and doubled dies. To determine if your coin is a genuine error, here are a few steps you can take:
- Research: Check error coin databases. The PCGS and NGC websites are great places to start.
- Consult Experts: Consider joining forums like Coin Community or reaching out to reputable dealers who specialize in error coins.
- Grading: Since you mentioned the coin is graded MS-65, ensure that you have clean, high-quality images for any online inquiries.
Lastly, if you can share a photo, that would help the community determine if it’s a mint error or post-mint damage. Best of luck with your Buffalo!
5 Likes
I agree with @CoinWizard99! Error coins can be tricky to assess. I once had a similar experience with a 2005 Buffalo that had a weird scratch. After posting it in a few forums and getting feedback, I realized it was actually just wear from circulation… not an error. Definitely try to get a photo and post it here!
3 Likes
Hi @CoinExplorer88! As someone who’s dabbled in error coins for a few years, I recommend checking references like the Cherrypickers’ Guide. Often, these guides outline common errors to look for. If you suspect it’s a mint error, you might even consider sending it to a grading service for authentication. They can provide a certificate that could increase its value. Good luck, and feel free to share pictures here for more insights!
2 Likes
Thanks for the tips, everyone! I’ll definitely check out the PCGS and NGC sites. I appreciate the help! I’ll try to get a good photo soon for you all to take a look at.
1 Like
That’s a good point, @SilverSeeker2023. I often find that many supposed ‘errors’ end up being post-mint damage. It’s good to take a closer look at the markings. A microscope can be handy for in-depth comparison!
4 Likes
I’ve had my fair share of Fraser Buffalo coins, and you’d be surprised how many come with unintentional marks due to handling. Always get a second opinion! I’d recommend posting on Reddit as well; the community there can be quite insightful. Just be ready for the wild theories!
5 Likes
@BuffaloBilly, I second that! The Reddit community can be both hilarious and informative. Just remember, with every coin there’s a tale. I have a friend who thought he had a rare error, but it turned out to be a coin stuck in a jar for ages! 
3 Likes
Thanks, @CoinNerd86! I’ve heard about the Cherrypickers’ Guide. I’ll get a copy and see what it has on these design discrepancies. I guess it pays to do a little detective work sometimes!
2 Likes