Hey everyone! As a growing enthusiast of DMPL (Deep Mirror Prooflike) coins, I’ve been diving into the fascinating world of potential errors that can be found in this series. Recently, I came across a 1999 DMPL Morgan Dollar that has been strikingly reflective, but I noticed some odd details around the edges that made me question its authenticity.
I’ve done some digging and found that errors can vary widely, from minor die cracks to more pronounced features. However, spotting these requires a keen eye and sometimes, a bit of extra research. I’m curious—how do you guys approach evaluating DMPL coins for errors? What specific markers do you look for, and how do you verify their authenticity?
I’d love to hear your personal stories or methods! Have you come across any surprising finds? Let’s discuss our techniques and maybe even learn from each other’s experiences.
Looking forward to your thoughts!
Great topic, CoinEnthusiast89! I’ve been collecting DMPL coins for a few years, and I can tell you that spotting errors is part art, part science. When evaluating a DMPL coin, here are some specific markers I look for:
- Surface Quality: Look for any signs of scratches or blemishes; the mirror-like finish should be pristine.
- Edge Details: Check for any anomalies like die cracks or uneven lettering.
- Light Testing: I often use a flashlight to see how light interacts with the coin’s surface. Errors might show up as variations in reflectivity.
Furthermore, I always compare coins with documented errors from trusted sites like
PCGS or
NGC to see if it’s officially recognized. I once found a 1998 DMPL with a die crack that turned out to be a known error—definitely a highlight of my collection! Hope this helps!
Let’s keep the discussion going!
5 Likes
@CoinMaster77, those tips are solid! I’d like to add that I personally prefer to use magnification tools like a jeweler’s loupe. It’s amazing how many small details you can miss with the naked eye. Just this week, I was checking out a 2000 DMPL, and zooming in revealed some unexpected clash marks. Always a thrill to discover something new, even after years of collecting!
3 Likes
I totally agree with you, @CoinMaster77, the surface quality is key! I once bought a DMPL that looked perfect at a glance, but under light, the edges were chipped. It was so disappointing! I think it’s important to do your homework before a purchase. Online forums can also be a great resource to validate suspicions about coins. Any advice on where to find reputable sellers?
2 Likes
Good point, @CollectorChick92! I always use established sellers on eBay or local coin shops that are well-reviewed. Plus, relying on auction houses can yield some excellent finds. Always make sure to ask for certificates or documentation when buying DMPL coins, especially if they claim to have errors. It’s better to be safe than sorry!
4 Likes
Great thread, everyone! I’ve experienced my fair share of misidentified coins, especially in the DMPL category. A common misconception is that all DMPL coins must have errors. I believe it’s also crucial to understand the grading and classification systems used by reputable organizations like US Mint and others. The grade, especially for DMPL, plays a significant role in determining value and collectibility.
1 Like
Thanks for the insights, everyone! I really appreciate the detailed tips—@CoinMaster77, that list is super helpful! I’ll definitely look into using a loupe like @SkepticalInvestor suggested. I think it could make a big difference in spotting those subtle errors. Keep the stories coming!
Joking aside, has anyone ever mistaken a minor tarnish for a DMPL error? I once thought I had discovered a new issue, only to find out it was just a little dirt. Lesson learned to clean before inspection, but be careful with that too!
5 Likes
@RetroNumismatist, you’ve nailed it! Buying from reputable sources is essential. When in doubt, attending coin shows can be beneficial; you get to see the coins in person, and you can often meet the sellers directly. Just recently at a show, I found a fantastic 1999 DMPL for a steal! You never know what surprises are waiting at these events.
4 Likes
Love the insights! I want to add that joining local coin clubs can also help you learn about spotting errors—many experienced collectors are eager to share their knowledge! I’ve been part of one for a few years, and it’s been invaluable. Plus, they often have community days where you can bring in coins to get feedback from more seasoned pros.
2 Likes
Quick tip! If you think you’ve found an error in a DMPL, always double-check your findings against online resources or forums before making any decisions. It’s easy to get excited and jump into conclusions, especially with so many counterfeit coins out there. A second pair of eyes can often help differentiate between a true collectible and a simple misprint.
3 Likes
Absolutely agree, @SilverSeeker007! There are so many resources available. I frequently use websites like CoinTalk and specific Facebook groups dedicated to modern coin errors. Just recently, I was able to confirm the authenticity of a coin I found at a flea market through those communities!
2 Likes