Hey fellow collectors! I’ve been diving deeper into reverse proof coins lately, and I have to admit, I’m a bit torn on their long-term value. I recently picked up a 2021 Reverse Proof Silver Eagle, and it’s stunning! The contrast between the mirrored fields and frosted design really catches the eye. My initial thoughts were that such a unique look would carry some value in the future, but I find myself wondering if that’s just wishful thinking.
After doing some research, I’ve seen mixed opinions online. Some collectors swear by their potential to appreciate in value, while others argue they’re just a passing trend. I noticed that certain limited mintage reverse proofs have fetched quite a bit during auction, but then again, a lot depends on market demand. I’ve always focused on coins I genuinely love, but I’m curious if others here have had experiences—good or bad—with reverse proofs.
What’s your take on this? Have you noticed any trends in the market for reverse proof coins? And do you think they’re a good long-term investment or more of a collector’s novelty? I’d love to hear your stories and insights!
Reverse proof coins can indeed be a double-edged sword when it comes to investing. Personally, I’ve had mixed results. I invested in a 2019 Reverse Proof Silver Eagle last year, and while it looked beautiful, I struggled to find buyers at a price I was satisfied with. The aesthetics are fantastic; however, the market can be quite fickle. Here’s what I’ve noticed:
- Limited mintage tends to do better.
- Time of release matters – some years do better than others.
- Condition is king; make sure to get your coins graded if they’re valuable.
Overall, I think they can be good investments, but it really depends on the specific coin and timing. I’d encourage you to keep your eye on auction sites for trends!
@CoinGuru88, have you checked sites like
PCGS or
NGC for historical data on sales? That might help gauge potential value.
5 Likes
Thanks for sharing your experiences, @SilverStackJoe! I did notice that the 2019 and 2021 Reverse Proof Silver Eagles seem to have a lot of buzz around them. I’ll definitely look at the historical sales you mentioned on PCGS. It’ll give me a clearer picture of where things might head in the future!
3 Likes
I think reverse proof coins are beautiful but can be a mixed bag for investment! Just a few months back, I sold a 2014 Reverse Proof Gold Buffalo for a decent profit. However, I’ve also seen many that plummeted in value shortly after their release. It often feels like a gamble. I’d suggest only buying what you truly love and can afford to hold for the long haul. Anyone else have a crazy reverse proof story? 
2 Likes
Totally agree, @NumisNerd92! I had a similar experience with a 2020 Reverse Proof that I thought would be a goldmine, but it barely appreciated at all. Now I stick to coins I genuinely like. By the way, does anyone here ever invest just for fun? It can be stressful otherwise! 
1 Like
My advice: don’t just invest based on a coin’s looks. Reverse proofs are a niche part of coin collecting, and trends can change quickly. Look at demand and market cycles closely. I’ve got several beauties in my collection, including a few MS69 graded pieces, but I treat them as collector pieces rather than strictly investments. Keep what you love! 
4 Likes
Absolutely, @CoinLover99! It really is about what you find personally valuable. Many collectors get caught up in the investment side and forget to enjoy the hobby. It’s easier to sell them when you’re passionate about them too. Maybe we should all plan a get-together to share our favorites! 
2 Likes
In my experience, certain reverse proofs are definitely worth it! I mean, just look at the 2011 Reverse Proof Silver Eagle—it’s a classic. Its value has stood the test of time, and the rarity is something to consider. I agree with others that it’s vital to follow the trends. However, if a coin has historical significance, it often keeps its value much longer.
3 Likes
@RarityHunter88, very interesting point about historical significance! I hadn’t thought about that angle. I’ll definitely look into some of the older reverse proofs; perhaps they’ll have some staying power compared to newer issues. Thanks for the insight!
2 Likes
I have to agree with @NumisNerd92 on the investment aspect. It’s tricky! I bought several last year but sold them at a loss. One lesson learned, though: always follow market trends before diving in. Anyone here use online pricing guides frequently? They help immensely in decision-making!
3 Likes
I’ve used various guides, @CoinCollector12! The NGC price guide is my go-to. It’s super helpful for keeping track, especially with fluctuating markets. Also, there’s a great community aspect if you participate in discussions there!
1 Like