Hey everyone! I recently added a DMPL (Deep Mirror Proof Like) coin to my collection and, after some close inspection, I noticed a small scratch on the obverse. It’s a stunning piece from the 1970s, showcasing that beautiful reflective surface you look for in DMPLs. However, I’m genuinely curious about how this scratch will impact its grading and overall value.
From what I’ve gathered in my research, a DMPL grade can really be affected by any surface blemishes, but I’m not sure how significant a minor scratch would be. Does anyone have experience in this area? I’ve seen some grading guides, but they often seem subjective when it comes to defining what constitutes a ‘minor’ issue versus a more severe one. Any insights on how this scratch might be viewed by professional graders would be super helpful!
I’d love to hear your thoughts! Do you think it’s worth getting it graded despite this scratch? How much do you think such imperfections typically devalue a coin? Looking forward to hearing from you all!
Great question, CoinEnthusiast87! A DMPL coin’s value can indeed take a hit due to surface distractions like scratches. When evaluating a coin, graders consider luster, surface quality, and overall eye appeal. Even a minor scratch can detract from that mirror-like finish, which is a hallmark of a DMPL. Generally, here’s how I’d break it down:
- If the scratch is superficial and not deep enough to disrupt the reflective quality, you might still hold onto a decent grade (MS 65 or lower).
- If it’s deep or quite visible, it could push down to MS 62 or lower, depending on the other attributes of the coin.
- For value, I’d expect a DMPL in MS 67 condition to command a premium, maybe 30-40% less in lower grades due to the scratch.
Considering the era of your coin, I’d recommend weighing the cost of grading vs. its potential market value. Check out the resources on
PCGS for more info on grading nuances. Good luck!
5 Likes
I feel you, CoinEnthusiast87! I recently picked up a DMPL and found a tiny scratch too. It disappointed me at first, but then I realized that coins can have character! However, as CoinExpert101 mentioned, scratches do impact grade and value. If the scratch doesn’t break the surface luster, it’s not as bad as it seems. I’d suggest showing it to a local dealer for a second opinion before grading it officially.
2 Likes
Thanks for the insights, CoinExpert101! You’ve given me a lot to consider about grading and value. I guess I need to evaluate if the scratch really detracts from the overall beauty of the coin. Considering the potential devaluation, I’m leaning towards getting it graded as well to have a professional opinion. @CollectorChick did you end up grading your DMPL?
3 Likes
Actually, I decided not to grade it. The cost was a bit steep for what I felt would be a lower score. I’m keeping it in my personal collection, though. I like to think of it as a little reminder of my journey in coin collecting, scratches and all! Plus, it adds a story to the coin—like, who knows where it’s been? 
4 Likes
Don’t stress too much about the scratch! Often, the rarity of a DMPL coin from the 1970s can still carry substantial value, even with minor imperfections. I’d suggest researching recent auction prices for similar coins to get a gauge on its market worth. For a small scratch, you may only lose a few hundred dollars in the grand scheme of things.
1 Like
I’m no expert, but I’ve heard that some graders can be very picky. It’s all in the details! I’d recommend you make sure that the scratch isn’t too deep. If it catches the light in a certain way, it might stand out more than you’d like. Good luck, and I hope you get a good grade! 
Thanks for the encouragement, MintGuy77! I will definitely look into those auction prices to see how they compare. The rarity aspect is what intrigued me about the coin in the first place. It still deserves a place in my collection regardless of minor imperfections!
2 Likes
For a final note, consider reaching out to a grading service directly, CoinEnthusiast87. Services like NGC or even the ones that PCGS provides can give you insight on how they might view your coin specifically. Many collectors often get pre-grading services which can help determine if it’s worth sending in. Having the professionals give you an honest evaluation can go a long way!
3 Likes