Hey fellow collectors! Lately, I’ve been diving deeper into my collection of Fraser Buffalo coins, and I can’t shake the feeling that some years are way too overlooked. After some recent finds at a local coin show, particularly a 1926 with beautiful luster, I started to question which years or varieties deserve more love from our community.
I’ve done a bit of research, and while many collectors rave about the 1936 and 1913 varieties, I’m really curious about the 1921. It seems like a decent year that often gets lost in the shuffle, yet I’ve found some interesting examples in higher grades that made me think twice. They have that striking detail and color that can turn heads! Have any of you come across some underappreciated years or varieties that need their moment in the spotlight?
Let’s share our thoughts! I’d love to hear about your favorites and any tips for finding these hidden gems. What do you think about the 1921 or any other years that may surprise newcomers in the game?
I totally get what you’re saying about the 1921! I think it’s often overlooked because collectors chase the big names like the 1913 or 1936, but the 1921 has some unique characteristics that stand out. I’ve recently acquired a few pieces in MS65 and MS66 grades, and the detail on them is phenomenal. The luster and subtle toning really pop under the right light. Plus, I’ve seen them go for less compared to the more celebrated years, making it a great buy for collectors looking to expand without breaking the bank. Have you noticed how most people don’t give 1921 the attention it deserves? PCGS has some great info on this too.
5 Likes
Thanks for your insight, @CoinCollector77! It’s nice to hear about your experiences with the 1921. I agree, the luster can be stunning if you find the right piece. I’ve been tempted to pick up more examples myself after seeing what you mentioned. Have you found any reliable sources online to help spot good deals on these?
2 Likes
As for underrated varieties, have you guys checked out the 1929? It’s a year that doesn’t get as much hype, but I picked one up recently in MS64 and was very surprised by its quality. The relief is higher, and I think it’s got a lot of potential for appreciation!
- Why I think it matters:
- Rarity: Fewer coins survive in higher grades.
- Market: It’s under the radar right now.
You might want to keep an eye on those too!
3 Likes
Definitely! I think the 1924 is also quite underrated. I stumbled upon one at a local show last month and couldn’t believe the detail compared to other years. Everyone’s usually focused on the big fancy years, but sometimes it’s those lower-profile years that can really surprise you with their quality. Plus, they often come at better prices! NGC has some good grading insights on those.
4 Likes
I hadn’t considered the 1924, @SilverScribe! Thanks for the tip. I’ll definitely look into that. It’s funny how the lesser-known years can end up being some of the favorites—like hidden treasures waiting to be discovered!
1 Like
Great points! The 1929 is a fantastic coin as well. I actually purchased a batch of mixed years recently and found a couple of 1929’s there. They have unique characteristics: there’s a distinct softness to the strike that isn’t found in many other years. I’m glad more people are noticing these hidden gems! Are you planning to focus on just one year at a time, or are you thinking about a broader approach for your collection? 
2 Likes
Why did the coin collector break up with his girlfriend? Because she took all his change! 
But on a serious note, I think the 1930s ones often get overlooked too! Anyone have thoughts on those?
2 Likes
Haha, @JokesterJoe! Classic! And the 1930s do have their charm. I’ve seen some nice gradings in those years too, especially the 1935. I think they sometimes get pushed aside in favor of the 36! What do you think about the prices for those—it seems like they fluctuate a lot?
2 Likes
Absolutely agree! The 1935 really does slip through the cracks. When I first started collecting, I thought the prices were going to be higher based on their quality. It’s surprising how some coins that should be more popular often have lower market values. I guess there’s always a new trend, huh? It’ll be interesting to see how the market shifts in the next few years.
2 Likes
Good point, @NumismaticsNerd! The market does seem to play favorites sometimes. I guess it all comes down to personal connections collectors make with specific years. It’s all about finding those coins that resonate with you!
2 Likes