Hey fellow collectors! Lately, I’ve been diving deep into the world of graded coins, and I can’t help but wonder about the value proposition of purchasing a PR70 over lower grades. I recently came across a stunning PR70 2020 Silver Eagle at a local show, but it comes with a hefty price tag. I’ve always been a firm believer in allocating my budget towards quality pieces, but is that prospect really worth the extra cash?
From my research, I’ve noted that while PR70 coins are seen as the pinnacle of condition, the real question is whether they maintain their value over time compared to coins graded PR69 or PR68. I’ve seen some serious price fluctuations recently, and it makes me ponder—are collectors truly willing to pay up for that perfect grade? Plus, I’ve noticed that some PR69s get just as much love in auctions and appear to have solid resale value.
So what do you all think? Is the premium for PR70s a sound investment for the future, or are we just caught up in the allure of perfection? Have any of you had experiences that might shed light on the longevity of these coins’ values? Let’s discuss!
I think it really depends on what you’re looking for as a collector. PR70 coins, like the one you mentioned, can command high premiums simply because they are considered the best of the best. However, I have seen PR69s maintain their value quite well, sometimes even outperforming PR70s at auctions. The difference in price can be steep, but I feel that the market plays a big role in these decisions. If the demand for perfect coins rises, PR70s might be a worthwhile investment in the long run. But if you’re more budget-conscious or just starting out, a PR69 can be a great alternative without compromising on aesthetic value. What’s your experience with PR69s, @CoinGuru88?
5 Likes
Thanks for your insight, @SilverSeeker92! I totally see your point. I’ve noticed that some collectors do seem to have a preference for the higher grades, which can drive price up. I guess it could also depend on whether the coin is part of a personal collection or an investment strategy. Have you ever sold a PR69 and been surprised by how much it went for?
2 Likes
As a seasoned collector, I can vouch for a few key aspects when it comes to PR70s versus lower grades:
- Market demand—trends fluctuate. Keep an eye on auction results.
- Future potential—PR70s do seem to appreciate faster, but it varies by the series.
- Personal attachment—if it’s a piece you love, its investment potential might be secondary.
Personally, I have a PR70 Gold Eagle, and while it was a steep investment, I’ve seen it hold its value quite well. On the other hand, I have a few PR69s that have appreciated nicely too. In the end, it comes down to the collector’s personal goals! What series are you most interested in?
7 Likes
Everyone loves a good PR70, but I think the hype can sometimes overshadow the actual worth. At the end of the day, it’s about what you value in your collection. If you’re a long-term investor, yes, consider the PR70. But if you’re a collector without the budget, a lower grade might be just as fulfilling. I mean, it’s all about the beauty of the coin, right? Plus, you can find some hidden gems in the PR69 range that are just as stunning.
4 Likes
Great points, @NumismaticNerd! I’m definitely leaning towards keeping my collection focused on the series I love rather than just the grading. It’s fascinating how subjective the coin market can be. I’m currently trying to explore some vintage coins as well. Any recommendations on which series are more reliable in terms of appreciation?
3 Likes
Absolutely, @CoinCollector123! The emotional aspect of collecting is sooo important. I’ve attached my PR69 Silver Eagle to my childhood memories of coin shows with my grandfather. The value is there, but so is the nostalgia. Sometimes, the connection with a piece of history is what truly counts. And to add a little humor—my grandmother thinks any coin that isn’t PR70 is basically just ‘change’! 
6 Likes
Honestly, it’s a mixed bag. While PR70s can look pristine, some PR69 coins can surprise you in terms of quality. I remember buying a PR69 coin thinking it was worth a gamble, and I ended up getting a great offer when I flipped it later. Sometimes, it’s about finding the right collectors who see the value in less than perfect grades. If it’s primarily for investment, PR70s might be a safer bet, but it also depends on the coin. What specific features do you look for when considering purchasing a higher-grade coin?
5 Likes
One key feature to evaluate is the eye appeal. Does it stand out in terms of luster and overall visual quality? My PR70 caught my eye instantly—smooth surfaces and beautiful coloration. In contrast, some PR69s have stunning frosted details that can blow your mind! When negotiating or purchasing, always consider NGC’s resources for grading comparisons. @CoinSnob88, how was your experience with selling that PR69? Did it exceed your expectations?
3 Likes
All said and done, it’s also about trends. In recent years, PR70s have seen value drops in certain markets. It’s always wise to keep a close watch on auction trends and dealer reports. Sometimes a savvy collector can capitalize on moments when people are less focused on the highest grades. Consider subscribing to newsletters from PCGS for updates! Worthy of mention that the best grades don’t always guarantee the best returns. Know your market!
4 Likes
Thanks for the insightful comments on market trends, @EagleEye98! It seems like having a strong grasp of current market conditions is vital for making sound investment decisions. I’m definitely keeping that in mind as I explore my options. Have you had any particular coins that fluctuated wildly in value, either positively or negatively? Would love to hear your experiences!
2 Likes