I’ve recently been diving deeper into the world of D over S coins, and I have to say, the error intrigues me more than I expected! Just last week, I picked up a 1968 D over S Lincoln penny in what I would rate as a solid AU condition. The details are sharp, and the mint mark really pops—definitely gives a little extra flair to the piece.
That said, I can’t help but wonder about their actual standing in the collector’s market. Are these coins overrated due to the hype around them, or underrated because perhaps fewer collectors are aware of their significance? I’ve read mixed opinions from various numismatic forums and a few pricing guides, but I feel like there’s room for more discussion.
From my perspective, while they are fascinating, their value might not reflect the excitement surrounding them. Is it the rarity that drives their appeal, or is it just the allure of an error coin? What do you all think? Are D over S coins worthy of the attention they get, or are we just chasing a trendy rabbit hole?
What are your experiences with them? Have any of you invested in D over S coins? Would love to hear your thoughts!
I think D over S coins are definitely underrated! The 1968 D over S penny you mentioned is a classic example. These errors often get overshadowed by more widely recognized varieties, but they can be quite valuable in certain conditions. Personally, I’ve had a 1960 D over S in my collection that I stumbled upon in a roll of pennies—totally unexpected! The thrill of finding one adds to their allure, and I believe that the current market just hasn’t caught up with their potential value as more collectors become aware of their significance.
In terms of investment, I would say they can be a solid choice, especially with the right grade and condition. Some collectors tend to overlook them simply because they aren’t as mainstream, but those who do chase them often reaps the rewards later. Overall, there’s a lot of room for appreciation in the D over S market!
What condition did you get yours in?
5 Likes
Thanks for the insight, @NumisNerd78! Mine’s in AU, which I think helps its visual appeal. I’m curious, though—what do you think drives the hype around D over S coins? Is it just the error appeal or the actual rarity that collectors chase? I feel like there’s quite a debate going on.
2 Likes
In my opinion, D over S coins are overrated, especially for people who think they can get rich quickly from them. Sure, they have their charm and historical significance, but the market for error coins can be fickle. I own a couple of them, but I’ve seen prices fluctuate significantly based on trends rather than true value. It’s essential to not just chase the next hot error but to really focus on what you love to collect.
That said, I do agree that when you find a nice specimen, like the 1968 D over S, it’s a fantastic feeling. You just have to treat them like you would with any collectible—invest with your heart. Don’t let the hype cloud your judgment!
3 Likes
Totally agree with @CollectorGuru3! The hype can sometimes create an unrealistic expectation for coins like these. I think some collectors jump into the frenzy without understanding the actual market dynamics, and they end up regretting it. Always keep an eye on reputable sources like PCGS or NGC to gauge true values and trends. Collect what you love! In the end, that’s what really matters.
1 Like
For me, D over S coins are a bit of both—overrated and underrated! Let me explain: they’re often marketed as rare finds, which creates a bubble of hype, but when you dig deeper, some are genuinely scarce in higher grades. I recently found a 1970 D over S—not the most coveted year, but I was thrilled nonetheless!
- They can be fun to collect.
- Some years really are challenging to find.
- Bubbles can burst quickly with trends.
So while some might be overrated, there’s definitely an underrated charm to them too. Just don’t let your wallet be your only guide, you know?
4 Likes
Really interesting points by everyone! I hadn’t thought about the market bubble aspect until @PennyPro82 mentioned it. The sentiment around these coins could definitely lead collectors to overestimate their value. I guess balance between passion and market awareness is key. How do you all feel about D over S coins as investments? Are you willing to hold them long-term?
2 Likes
Exactly, @CoinDabbler99! It’s all about finding the balance. I believe every collector has different motivations, and as long as they’re informed, that’s what matters. I do see D over S coins being more appreciated over time, especially if the current errors trend continues. Have you all noticed that interest spikes around certain error coins every few years? Sometimes, I think they become collector’s items in cycles.
3 Likes
I’ll admit, I used to see D over S coins as just another error, but the more I read about their history and significance, the more I appreciate them. They have this unique story that other error coins sometimes lack. Value aside, they are really interesting pieces to own, and they definitely spark conversations among fellow collectors!
I’m particularly fond of the ones from the 1960s. If anyone is looking for informational resources, I found this neat guide on USMint about error coins that might help new collectors get acquainted with this niche. Let’s keep sharing our thoughts and experiences!
6 Likes