Hey fellow collectors! I recently picked up a 2021 American Silver Eagle at my local coin shop, and while I was excited about the mint condition, I noticed a few bag marks on it. I’ve been digging into how much these marks actually affect a coin’s value and would love to hear about your experiences.
From what I’ve gathered, the impact of bag marks can really depend on the type of coin and its grade. For example, while my Silver Eagle might lose a bit of its premium due to those small abrasions, I’ve heard that bag marks are much less significant on circulated coins compared to ultra-low mintage pieces or those in higher grades like MS-70. Personally, I think it’s a shame that such minor imperfections can greatly affect resale potential. It makes me wonder if certain coins, like classic numismatic types, are more forgiving when it comes to these marks.
Have you noticed huge differences in value based on bag marks in your collection? Are there specific types of coins where these marks are a dealbreaker? Looking forward to hearing your thoughts and any tips you might have about buying coins that may show some wear but could still be great specimens for the long haul!
Bag marks can significantly impact a coin’s value, especially for higher-grade pieces. In my experience, a bag mark on a coin graded MS-70 can reduce its value by as much as 20% to 30%. For example, I had a 2014 Silver Eagle that I believed was pristine until I noticed a small bag mark. It downgraded my thoughts from selling it at a high premium to getting only face value offers. On the other hand, in lower grades (like AU or less), the effect isn’t as pronounced. Circulated coins often bear many imperfections, and collectors generally accept them as part of the charm of a vintage piece.
I agree with your point about modern coins like the American Silver Eagle. They’re mass-produced, so buyers are less strict about minor imperfections. Conversely, with classic numismatic coins, buyers look for the absolute best condition. So the demand tends to be more sensitive to those bag marks.
- Consider similar coins in your collection and their market responses.
- Always check the coins’ grades with proper evaluation criteria.
- Explore articles on PCGS or NGC for more insights PCGS NGC.
5 Likes
In my view, bag marks can be a major dealbreaker for some coins, particularly those that are supposed to be pristine. I remember buying a beautiful 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln penny; it was in great condition, but once I got it certified, they flagged a couple of bag marks that dropped its grade to a consciousness-shocking EF-45. The difference in price from what I paid versus what it was worth was pretty eye-opening.
But I do think classic coins tend to be a bit more forgiving. If they have some character and history, I think collectors appreciate them despite the marks. What do others think?
3 Likes
Thanks for sharing that experience, @NumismaticsNerd! It’s interesting to hear about classic coins like the V.D.B. penny being affected by bag marks. I’ve noticed that as well—certain coins really do seem to hold their value irrespective of those imperfections. It’s like they develop a personality! I’ll definitely keep this in mind when I look for more pieces. Cheers!
2 Likes
Bag marks? They’re the never-ending struggle of a collector! I personally wouldn’t sweat minor bag marks too much on bullion coins like Silver Eagles because their value is tied more to metal content than collector demand. That said, if one is planning to resell, bag marks can definitely lessen how much you can ask for it.
My last experience involved purchasing a 2020 Silver Eagle that had minor marks yet the dealer offered it at a sharp price. So I grabbed it without hesitation. You can always do some light polishing, but that’s risky business! What are your thoughts on polishing?
4 Likes
Interesting point about polishing! @SilverStacker101, I’ve always heard to avoid polishing coins—doesn’t it ruin their grade? If a coin has bag marks but is otherwise great, I think it might be better just to leave it as is. Would love to hear more about what others do in this situation!
3 Likes
You make some solid points, @CoinExpert88. Investment-grade coins, especially those in high MS grades, are definitely more sensitive to marks. From my experience, I’ve seen that rare coins like key-date Morgan dollars can drop in value drastically if even a single bag mark is detected.
I think collectors need to be strategic. When selling, be sure to disclose bag marks and their potential impact. Honesty goes a long way and often maintains trust even if the item’s not in flawless condition.
5 Likes
@GoldDigger, for sure! Key dates are a whole different beast. I recall selling a 1921 Peace Dollar with a visible bag mark, and even in decent condition, collectors were quick to negotiate down from my asking price. It’s almost like sharks smelling blood! 
But that’s part of the thrill, isn’t it? Getting a good deal while also learning about the market’s dynamics!
7 Likes
Polishing coins can be a double-edged sword. While it can enhance their appearance, it usually destroys the coin’s original luster, which is vital for a good grade. I’d advise only cleaning coins if they’re in really bad shape and you’re sure it’s a common piece. If it’s anything of potential value, better to leave it as-is! There’s always someone looking for original coins in their natural state.
6 Likes
Great discussion! I’d like to add, when purchasing coins, it’s crucial to check for bag marks from the get-go. In my latest buy, I overlooked subtle marks on a Buffalo Nickel. Ends up, it affected its value quite a bit when I tried reselling! Lesson learned: Always inspect closely, and don’t rely only on the dealer’s word! What do others do to spot these marks?
4 Likes
I’ve noticed a huge variance in how bag marks affect value depending on the coin’s scarcity. For instance, a lesser-known coin may suffer less from bag marks than a low-mintage item like the 1996 Silver Eagle. Scarce coins demand perfection. So, it’s a good call to choose what to invest in based on their likely future value and whether they’re forgiving regarding bag marks. What do you all think about investing in lesser-known coins instead of the heavy hitters?
3 Likes