Hey everyone! I’m relatively new to the world of coin collecting, and I’ve been trying to familiarize myself with grading coins. Recently, I’ve been using PCGS Photograde as my go-to resource. I appreciate its visual comparisons, but I’m curious about how reliable you all find it when it comes to accurately assessing a coin’s condition.
I recently picked up a 1943 Steel Penny, which I initially thought was in decent shape. However, after referencing PCGS Photograde, I’m torn between calling it a Fine or a Very Fine. I did some background research on the right terminology and what to look for regarding luster and wear, but the grading can feel pretty subjective at times.
What have your experiences been with Photograde? Do you think it matches up with what you’ve seen in hand? Also, any tips for someone just starting out? I’d love to hear your thoughts and perhaps share some favorite resources you’ve found helpful for grading!
Welcome to the hobby! I think you’re on the right track with using PCGS Photograde. It’s a great starting point for visual aids. When I began collecting, I relied heavily on it too! Just keep in mind that lighting and the coin’s surface can change how you perceive its grade. I always suggest getting a good magnifier to inspect for scratches or toning that might not be evident in a photo. Also, practice makes perfect. Perhaps you could make a habit of checking the same coin on different days to see if your grading perception improves. Good luck with your collection! Great choice with the 1943 Steel Penny, by the way!
Have you thought about joining a local coin club or attending shows? It can really help to see coins in person and get advice from experienced collectors!
5 Likes
Thanks, CoinCollector99! I appreciate the tips! I’ll definitely get a magnifier for better examination. Coin clubs sound interesting, I’ll look into that! I want to learn from others’ experiences as well.
1 Like
PCGS Photograde is a good resource, but grading can indeed be subjective. My advice is to use it in conjunction with other resources. NGC has a similar tool, and comparing both sides can provide a broader perspective. There are also forums like this one where members post their coins and get opinions! Also, great to hear you’re diving into collecting. The 1943 Steel Penny is a nice piece – it’s like a gateway to the fascinating history of coinage.
4 Likes
Thanks, SilverSeeker22! I hadn’t thought about cross-referencing with NGC. I’ll check it out for sure! Community opinions sound quite helpful.
2 Likes
As a relatively experienced collector, I find that PCGS Photograde is a beneficial starting point, but it’s essential to develop your own grading skills over time.
- Take notes
- Compare coins in hand with graded examples
- Watch YouTube tutorials on grading basics
Coin grading is a blend of art and science, and confidence will come with exposure. That being said, never hesitate to ask for opinions like you are doing now! We all started somewhere, and the community is willing to help.
3 Likes
Great tips, Numismatist101! I’ll definitely keep an eye out for videos and tutorials. Thanks for sharing your insights!
1 Like
Hey @CoinExplorer88, don’t sweat the grading! Even seasoned collectors can argue over a coin’s grade! It really comes down to personal interpretation. My suggestion is to enjoy the process and not stress about the numbers too much. The 1943 Steel Penny is noteworthy because it’s a piece of history, don’t forget to appreciate it! Also, if ever in doubt, you can ask here or look at US Mint for historical context.
3 Likes
Thanks for the encouragement, TokenTrekker! I really want to enjoy collecting rather than stressing over grades, so your perspective helps a lot!
2 Likes
I second what TokenTrekker said! Don’t take grading too seriously when you’re starting. It’s all about the joy of discovery and finding pieces that resonate with you. As you progress, you’ll find your rhythm. Plus, sometimes you might find a coin that surprises you. It’s not always about perfection but about enjoying the journey!
3 Likes
Regarding your 1943 Steel Penny, make sure to check for the Die Variety too! There are several different mintages. You may have a rare one on your hands! Also consider referring to PCGS Coin Facts for more detailed information on specific coins.
2 Likes