Hey fellow collectors! Lately, I’ve been eyeing my West Point coins and thinking it might be time to let go of a few. I’ve got a 2019-W West Point American Silver Eagle in MS70 condition that I’m particularly considering selling, along with a couple of other commemoratives. The thing is, I’m a bit torn on the best approach to selling these beauties.
So, here’s my main question: What platforms have you all found to be the most reliable for trading coins like these? I’ve seen sites like eBay and AuctionZip get a lot of buzz, but I wonder if there’s a better niche marketplace specifically for collectible coins. Also, determining their worth has me scratching my head—are there good benchmarks for recent sales that I could reference?
I did a little research and found some recent auctions where similar coins sold for quite a bit, but I’m curious about your experiences. How do you determine the value of your coins before listing them? What methods or resources would you recommend? Let’s share some insights!
Hey CoinGuru88! I totally understand where you’re coming from. Selling coins can be a bit overwhelming. As for platforms, eBay is widely used and has a large audience, which can work to your advantage. However, for niche markets like West Point coins, I recommend checking out Coin Vault. They specialize in collectible coins and often have buyers specifically looking for items like yours. In terms of determining value, recent auction results are a fantastic starting point. Websites like PCGS provide valuation guides too. Just remember, condition matters a lot, especially if your American Silver Eagle is in MS70 condition! Good luck!
1 Like
Thanks for the tips, CoinMaster99! I appreciate the suggestions on platforms. I’ve heard mixed things about eBay, but maybe I should give it another shot. Never heard of Coin Vault, so I’ll check it out! Have you sold there before? What was your experience?
2 Likes
Hi! Just to add on to what CoinMaster99 mentioned, while eBay can be a great option, auction houses like Heritage Auctions are also fantastic, especially for high-value coins. They have experts who can help you gauge the right price and promote your coin effectively. Besides auction results, NGC has a good database for looking up auction prices specifically for the condition you have. Make sure to get your coin graded if you haven’t already, as it can significantly boost its selling price.
3 Likes
Great point, RareCoins4U! I haven’t sold through a traditional auction house yet, but I’ve heard excellent feedback. It’s essential to choose the right auction house based on the type of coins you’re selling. I think CoinGuru88 should definitely consider coin grading. It often provides a much clearer discussion around value too!
1 Like
Hey CoinGuru88! Selling coins can definitely be a bit tricky. I personally love using Amazon, especially for unique items, but it requires patience due to their fees. You want to ensure you’ll still make a profit. As for value, I just look at recent sales on marketplaces and compare. Also, remember that timing can affect your sales price—check how the market is doing for West Point coins.
1 Like
West Point coins have surged in popularity recently! I mostly use Facebook groups for selling, where collectors are eager. Just be cautious—always verify the buyer when using social platforms. I sold a couple earlier this year and had a great experience, but it’s essential to trust your gut. Good luck with your sale!
4 Likes
Thanks for sharing, Dave! Facebook groups sound interesting. I guess it’s like a mix of selling and community engagement, right? I’ll be cautious with whom I deal. Have any of you experienced any scams on those platforms?
2 Likes
Hey CoinGuru88! Scams can happen anywhere, so it’s smart to be cautious. Never send a coin before receiving payment—always opt for secure payment methods. I once had a close call, but I double-checked the buyer’s profile and avoided a nasty situation. Just be smart about it, and you’ll be fine!
3 Likes
Remember that the condition of your coins directly affects their value. Make sure to document everything with quality photos, especially if you decide to sell online. Clarity on your coin’s condition can prevent disputes later on, and it’s just a great practice overall!
A quick joke to lighten the mood: Why did the coin collector marry a bank teller? Because she had potential! 
But seriously, always ensure your grading is accurate to avoid being ‘tossed’ like loose change!
2 Likes