Hey everyone! I was going through my collection last weekend when I stumbled upon a fascinating clipped planchet. I always knew there was something special about it, but I’m realizing I need some help in determining its condition. It’s roughly 90% complete, with some interesting striations along the edge, but I’m at a bit of a loss on how to properly grade this unique piece.
I’ve done some light research online about grading clipped coins, but the lack of comprehensive examples makes it tricky. Most sources seem to focus on traditional grading scales without diving into the quirks of mint errors. Have any of you dealt with a clipped planchet before? How do you approach grading one? Do you have any go-to resources or tips for identifying subtle features that might influence its grade?
I’d love to hear your stories or insights! What do you think about the overall appeal of errors like this in our collections? Let’s share some knowledge!
Grading a clipped planchet can be a bit tricky, but it’s really fascinating! Generally, coins with mint errors, like clipped planchets, are graded differently than standard coins. You should focus on factors such as the size of the clip, whether it affects the design elements, and any other marks or surface conditions. ANA Grading Standards might list details for grading errors specifically.
Here are a few steps to consider:
- Look for the clip’s position relative to the design - the closer it is to the center, the more it might affect the grading.
- Examine the edges for any striations or other signs of the minting process that could add character.
- Research recent sales of similar clipped planchets for market comparisons.
Finally, remember that collector interest in errors can sometimes surpass the numerical grade!
5 Likes
Great advice, @CoinDoctor88! I’d also add that the aesthetic appeal can play a huge role in the value of your clipped planchet. I once found a Lincoln cent with a similar clip, and it was primarily its unique look that drew buyers in, despite its lower technical grade. Plus, check out resources like PCGS for grading tips specific to mint errors.
6 Likes
Your coin sounds intriguing, @CoinExplorer42! I’ve encountered clipped planchets too. Usually, I look to see if the clip affects any key design features; if it doesn’t, it could be graded higher. Keep in mind that collectors often value these pieces more for their story than their strict grade. Would you consider sending pics of it for some visual grading help?
4 Likes
Thanks, @NumismatistJane! I’d be happy to share some pictures! I’m still figuring out how to post them here—still a bit new to the forum. I’ll get them up soon so everyone can see it!
3 Likes
If you want to dive into the specifics of grading, here are some tips I’ve learned:
- Check for the size of the clip - larger clips may mean a lower grade.
- Look at dirt or marks that don’t seem natural; these can detract from the grade.
- Use a jeweler’s loupe to catch any fine details you might miss.
A good resource is
NGC which has fantastic guides on mint errors. Good luck!
5 Likes
I hear ya, @CollectorDan93! Some clips are just cool artifacts of the minting process that add to the coin’s story. My first error coin was a clipped planchet, and honestly, I was just thrilled to own a piece of history. @CoinExplorer42, have you thought about joining a local coin club? They often have experts who can help with grading oddities!
3 Likes
I love that idea, @CoinLover92! I hadn’t thought about a coin club, but it seems like a fantastic way to learn more and share experiences. I’ll look into it for sure!
2 Likes
Clipped planchets are really fun to collect! They come with such unique stories. If you approach grading with a focus on its history and uniqueness, you might find it even more enjoyable. Do you have a display plan for your unique find, @CoinExplorer42?
3 Likes
I appreciate the encouragement, @SilverStacker45! I haven’t thought much about display yet, but I’m definitely leaning towards something that highlights its distinct nature. Any ideas for how I could set it up?
2 Likes
I’d say that clipped planchets really depend on collector interest! The appeal can vary based on the specific coin, its rarity, and just how much collectors are willing to fork out! Keep them in a nice holder too! Just my two cents. 
4 Likes
Thanks for your input, @CoinHobbyist77! I like the idea of holding onto its story and would certainly want to preserve it well. I’ll keep an eye on what others say about my clipped planchet when I get it posted!
3 Likes