Hey fellow collectors! I just made a trade recently for a first strike coin that I’ve had my eye on for a while. It’s a 2021 Silver Eagle in MS70 condition, and the luster is just stunning under the right light. I was super excited about the trade, but now I’m second-guessing myself about whether I got a fair deal or not.
In prepping for the trade, I checked online prices and auction results, but I mostly relied on what I’ve seen on various forums and at coin shows. However, I feel like I might’ve missed some key points—like the scarcity or market demand for first strikes specifically. Given that the coin’s condition is top-notch, I was thinking it should hold a good value, yet I still want to know how everyone else determines if their trades are on the money.
So, have any of you traded for first strikes before? What indicators do you usually look for to gauge whether a deal is solid or not? I’d love to hear your thoughts on evaluating this kind of trade, especially how the condition should factor in with current market trends!
Congratulations on your trade! The 2021 Silver Eagle in MS70 is a fantastic coin, and it’s great to hear you’re excited about it! To determine if you got a good deal, you should consider several factors:
- Market Trends: Check recent auction results and sales on platforms like PCGS and NGC.
- Scarcity: First strike coins can be more sought after, so check the mintage rates.
- Overall Condition: The MS70 grade you mentioned is excellent. Additionally, look for any unique attributes, such as toning or special errors that might enhance value.
You might want to reach out to local dealers for insight on recent trade practices too. Good luck with your collection!
—
@CoinGuru88, what was the coin you traded for?
5 Likes
Thanks for the great tips, @SilverHunter42! To answer your question, I traded my 2020 American Samoa quarter in AU58 condition. I felt at the time it was a good swap, but now I’m wondering if the Silver Eagle will hold its value. Do you think trading down like this is common, or should I have held out for something better?
3 Likes
Don’t second-guess yourself too much, @CoinGuru88! The market does fluctuate, but if it’s a coin you admire and enjoy, that’s worth a lot. The MS70 grade is key, and Silver Eagles are popular among collectors. You could look into trends for specific years—2021 has been particularly strong. Additionally, if it’s a first strike, many collectors are willing to pay a premium for that, so I think it should hold its value well! It might just take some time for it to appreciate.
Maybe it would help to gather data on recent sales to ease your concerns?
2 Likes
Trade decisions are always tricky, but the Silver Eagles are in high demand. You might want to monitor platforms like eBay for the latest prices. Keep an eye on the completed listings section to see what they actually sell for, rather than just the listed price. A lot of folks get caught up in price listings without looking deeper. Also, if you haven’t done this already, consider setting alerts for similar coins—you can catch the next wave of pricing trends right from your inbox!
1 Like
As a fellow collector, I can understand your concerns about value. To me, the MS70 is crucial since it indicates the best condition, and first strikes tend to sell for a premium. The key factors to assess your trade include:
- Sales price trends in the past 6 months;
- The overall market sentiment for Silver Eagles, which has been quite favorable lately;
- Any potential increases in interest due to modern rarity trends.
Also, don’t forget emotional value—it’s about enhancing your collection, sometimes that’s worth more than the coin’s price tag!
Remember, even if the trade seems off now, the experience is valuable!
What did you learn from this trade?
4 Likes
Folks, let’s not forget that collecting should also be fun! @CoinGuru88, if you love the Silver Eagle and it fits your collection, that’s what really matters. Market values come and go, but your enjoyment won’t! And who knows? The value might surprise you down the line. Just remember to showcase it in good lighting, it’s striking under the right conditions! 
3 Likes
When evaluating the fairness of a trade, always remember to consider factors such as historical sales data, grading standards, and market demand. Have you considered checking out community sales platforms? They often have comparables, which might ease your mind about your trade being a good deal. It’s worth diving into!
Do you keep records of your trades? It might help to reflect on your decisions moving forward.
2 Likes
Absolutely, @CollectorChad! The joy of collecting is irreplaceable! @CoinGuru88, we can sometimes get obsessed with numbers and forget why we collect in the first place. Plus, your trading story adds depth to your collection. And hey, now you have a stunning Silver Eagle to show off!
1 Like
Edit: Just wanted to clarify my earlier comment—make sure to base your assessments not only on price but also on quality and demand! I think some people overlook intrinsic value factors, especially for popular coins. Happy trading, everyone!
Great point on intrinsic value, @NumismaticNerd88! I’ve realized that every coin tells a story, and that adds to its worth beyond just market trends. Thanks for all the insights, everyone. This has been super helpful!
2 Likes