I recently read about 1916-D error coins. Can anyone share their experiences with finding them, and what makes them so valuable?

Hey everyone! I’ve been diving deep into the world of error coins recently, and the 1916-D varieties have completely captured my attention. I came across several articles discussing their rarity and significance, but I’d love to hear more personal stories from you guys. Have any of you had the fortune of finding one of these elusive coins?

From what I gather, the 1916-D Mercury Dimes are particularly renowned due to their limited mintage and the unique characteristics that set them apart. I’ve read that the coin’s condition plays a huge role in its value, and those in mint state can fetch astronomical prices at auction! It’s fascinating to see how even minute flaws can create such demand in the collecting community. I must admit, I’ve had no luck spotting one at local shops, but I’m always on the lookout!

So, fellow collectors, what’s your experience with 1916-D error coins? Do you have any tips for identifying them or key places where you’ve managed to find rare coins? I’m eager to learn and hear all your stories!


The 1916-D Mercury Dime is truly a legend in the coin collector’s world. I had the incredible luck of finding one at a local estate sale a few years ago. It was in a mix of old coins, and I instantly recognized its value. The thrill of discovering it was unparalleled! In terms of identification, the 1916-D mark is essential, and the overall condition can range from badly worn to mint state. Here are some factors that contribute to its value:

  • Rarity: Only about 264,000 were minted, making it scarce.
  • Condition: Coins graded above AU (Almost Uncirculated) can command a premium.
  • Demand: Many collectors specifically seek out this coin due to its history.
If you're looking to buy or sell, keep an eye on auction sites like PCGS for recent sales data. Good luck in your hunt, and I hope you find one soon!
5 Likes

Wow, @RareCoinHunter, that’s an amazing find! I can only imagine the excitement you felt. I’ve been scouring flea markets and garage sales, but no luck yet. Do you have any tips on what specific details to look for in terms of grading?

3 Likes

In my experience, the best way to check for authentic 1916-D Dimes is to look at the Mint Mark. It should be located on the reverse, below the motto. Also, examine the details on the Liberty’s cheek and the lower wing of the eagle for wear. Coins like these often have distinct characteristics depending on their condition, so try to familiarize yourself with the different grades. You can find detailed grading guides on sites like NGC. Hope this helps!

4 Likes

Thanks for the advice, @OldSchoolCollector! I’ll definitely keep an eye on those details. I’ve read that the patina also plays a role in its value - is that true?

2 Likes

Absolutely! The patina can enhance the beauty and perceived value of the coin. A nice toning can indicate that a coin has been stored properly over the years, but too much tarnish might hurt its value. It’s all about finding that perfect balance. Keep looking, and I’m sure you’ll come across a gem!

3 Likes

I once thought I found a 1916-D in my change, but it was just a trick of the light – turned out to be a 2001-D! At least I can say I have a great story now. Just keep looking, and don’t forget to check your pockets after laundry - you never know what might show up!

2 Likes

@CoinExplorer99, for finding rare coins, I recommend checking out local coin shows. They often have dealers with high-end items, and you might just stumble upon a 1916-D! Plus, you can try bargaining for even better deals.

3 Likes