Hey everyone! So, I’ve been sorting through my collection, and to my surprise, I found a 1909 VDB penny with what looks like a pretty unusual die error. I’ve read about other collectors finding oddball errors on this iconic coin, but this one has me scratching my head. The condition is decent—definitely not uncirculated, but the error really stands out.
I did some digging online and didn’t find much information about die errors specific to the 1909 VDB. The error on my coin seems to involve some double-striking on the reverse, which gives it a sort of layered look. It’s not something I’ve seen on most of the examples shared in the forums. For those of you who have dealt with such variations, do you think this could significantly affect the coin’s value? I’m really curious since this could either be a cool addition to my collection or a potential money-maker.
What have your experiences been with die errors? Has anyone else spotted something unusual on their 1909 VDBs? And for pricing, what’s the range you all have encountered for similar coins? Let’s dig into this together!
Wow, that’s quite a find! The 1909 VDB is already a highly sought-after coin, and unusual die errors can certainly spike interest among collectors. If it truly has a double-struck appearance, it could potentially elevate its value significantly, depending on the severity and visibility of the error. I’ve come across a few variations in my own collection, including a 1909 VDB with a prominent die crack that really caught my eye. When evaluating the value of your coin, here’s what to consider:
- The visibility of the error
- Overall condition (graded coins can fetch a premium)
- Market demand—some collectors love quirky variations!
I’d estimate that pristine examples with die errors can go anywhere from a few hundred to over a thousand dollars. If you get it graded by an organization like
PCGS or
NGC, it’ll provide a proper assessment that could help in determining its market value. Good luck, and I’m excited to see how this unfolds for you!
5 Likes
Thank you for the detailed response, @coinexpert23! I’ve been wondering how the grading process works—do you think it’s worth the cost? And how do you usually determine if the error could be a significant value addition?
2 Likes
This really takes me back! I found a similar 1909 VDB with a weird edge defect a couple of years ago. It had a big impact on its condition and hence, its value. It’s funny how these errors can turn a coin into an oddity! As for the pricing, I’d suggest checking sites like eBay or Heritage Auctions to see what others are listing those with errors. Sometimes the market’s appetite can vary widely. Good luck with yours, and keep us updated!
3 Likes
@pennycollector88 that sounds intriguing! Do you still have that coin? I’d love to see a picture if you do. It’s amazing how just a small error can change everything. I recently got into die errors and they’ve turned out to be some of the most fascinating pieces in my collection.
4 Likes
Regarding the 1909 VDB, I think the rarity of a die error plays a huge role in adjustments to its value. Some errors are very common, while others are almost unique, which can lead to a significant price different. For example, a major double-strike can sometimes fetch a price above standard examples.
3 Likes
I actually do have some pictures! I’ll post them in the gallery section later. It’s probably a good idea for @coinhunter92 to post a picture of their find too. It can really help us evaluate it better!
2 Likes
@coinhunter92, grading should definitely be considered based on the value of your coin. If it’s a significant error, the cost of grading may be well worth it. Professional grading services can provide a clean label and enhance liquidity if you decide to sell in the future. NGC and PCGS are the two best companies known for grading coins accurately. However, always check their websites for the latest pricing and turn-around times.
5 Likes
Sounds like a fun coin to have! Just be careful with those double strikes—sounds like they could literally ‘double’ your trouble! 
But seriously, if you’ve got photos, we’d love to see!
1 Like