Hey fellow collectors! I’d love to share a little treasure I found while rummaging through my grandfather’s old coin collection—a 1909 V.D.B. penny! It’s been sitting in an album for decades, and I’m still buzzing with excitement over it. The condition seems decent, but there’s a slight wear on Lincoln’s profile. I’ve done some digging online, and I know the 1909 V.D.B. is iconic, particularly because of its controversial history.
This leads me to my main thought: how do we really assess its value? I see listings that vary widely in price, and it kind of blows my mind. I’ve read that a coin in mint condition can fetch a pretty penny (pun intended) but what about my piece? Does the wear significantly affect its market potential? I am particularly curious about whether it’s considered rare within certain grading ranges, or is it more about the demand in today’s market.
Has anyone else come across a similar find? Any insights on pricing or experiences with selling items like this would be greatly appreciated. Are there specific grading criteria or collectors to target if I choose to sell? Let’s discuss!
Congratulations on finding a 1909 V.D.B. penny! These coins are iconic and definitely valuable, especially among collectors. The demand for the 1909 V.D.B. is due in part to its historical significance and the fact that it was one of the first coins produced with the new Lincoln design. Grade plays a critical role in determining its market potential—a coin in MS65 can fetch thousands, while AG3 examples sell for much less. It would help to get your penny graded by a reliable service like PCGS or NGC. If it’s showing wear, that’ll certainly impact the value you might expect. Still, collecting is often about the passion behind the hunt! Have you thought about getting it appraised?
5 Likes
Thanks for the insights, @RareCoinHunter! I am considering getting it appraised, as I want to know its true value. It’s fascinating to think about its history, isn’t it? Total treasure hunt vibes! Has anyone else had theirs graded?
3 Likes
The 1909 V.D.B. penny is indeed a widely sought-after coin! Its rarity isn’t just about being old; the ‘V.D.B.’ initials on the back create a notable contrast to the other pennies of that era. If you’re looking for valuation guidance, you should check the most recent price guides on sites like US Mint or visit the NGC price database. Just a slight wear can drop the value significantly, so I recommend handling it carefully. Have you compared it to images of graded coins to estimate the grade? It can really help in knowing where you stand.
4 Likes
Absolutely, @NumismaticNerd! I recently sold my own 1909 V.D.B., and the grading made a huge difference in price. I went from expecting a few hundred to securing over a thousand because it was graded at MS64. If it’s showing wear, don’t be discouraged—there’s still a passionate community for these pieces. Just be transparent about its condition when selling it. How are you planning to sell it?
2 Likes
Thanks for sharing your experience, @CoinCollectorDan! I’m leaning towards online platforms like eBay or even local coin shows. It feels daunting, but I want to find the right audience. Any tips on what website to use?
3 Likes
Condition matters a lot, but so does the story! My dad had a similar penny that he passed down. It struck a conversation over family heritage at many family gatherings! Even if it doesn’t fetch top dollar, the sentimental value can be worth much more. Don’t forget to consider holding onto it for future generations! Just a thought! 
6 Likes
@OldTimerCoins You make an excellent point! Coins with history can definitely carry value beyond just what’s marked on a price guide. My coins often become conversation starters at family gatherings, too! Isn’t it funny how passionate we get over little pieces of metal? 
2 Likes
I wouldn’t sell it just yet, @CoinEnthusiast92! Prices for these coins fluctuate a lot. It might be worth waiting to see how the market develops. I heard that during big coin shows, the prices can shoot up! Keep your options open!
5 Likes
Hey, @CoinEnthusiast92! Just to add some humor- why did the penny break up with the nickel? Because it found someone a little more centsible! 
But on a serious note, coins like yours can definitely be worth a lot. Just watch out for counterfeiters when selling!
2 Likes
To evaluate your coin’s worth accurately, consider getting it certified by a professional grader. The grading scale from 1 (Poor) to 70 (Perfect) is critical for determining value. Many collectors refer to PCGS’s guide on grading for a detailed understanding. If there is any hint of cleaning, it can greatly diminish its value too. Keep an eye on those details!
3 Likes
Thanks for the helpful link, @ExpertGrader! I’ll definitely check that out before I make any decisions on selling. It’s amazing how even minor details can really change the coin’s value. 
2 Likes
Glad to hear that, @CoinEnthusiast92! Being informed is half the battle when it comes to coin collecting. Good luck with your journey in this exciting hobby!
2 Likes