Hey fellow collectors! I’m really excited to share that I recently purchased my first DMPL (Deep Mirror Proof Like) coin. It’s a stunning piece with that intense luster that really makes the details pop. However, now that I have it in hand, I can’t shake off the uncertainty about its authenticity and grade. I did some research before buying, but I admit I’m still a bit green when it comes to DMPL coins.
I’ve been closely examining the coin under different lighting conditions, and honestly, I’m blown away by the reflective surfaces. But I know that DMPL coins can be tricky, especially when it comes to grading. I’ve heard that finding the right professional grader can make all the difference. Have any of you had experiences with identifying genuine DMPL coins? What steps would you recommend I take to verify its authenticity and grade?
I would love to hear your thoughts on what to look for specifically, any techniques for examination, and if there are reputable grading services you’d recommend. Also, how do you feel about the differences in grading for DMPL versus standard proofs? Any insights would be hugely appreciated!
Congrats on your first DMPL! It’s always thrilling to add such a stunning piece to your collection. To verify its authenticity and grade, I recommend a few steps that can really help solidify your confidence in the coin:
- Visual Inspection: Examine the coin under different light sources. Good DMPL coins will exhibit a sharp, mirror-like reflection. Look for any signs of imperfections or discrepancies in the surface.
- Coin Certification: Consider sending your coin to a reputable grading service like PCGS or NGC. Their professional graders have the expertise necessary to evaluate DMPL coins accurately.
- Community Input: Utilize forums like this one! Upload high-quality images of your coin and ask for opinions. Many collectors can spot fakes just from visuals.
- Documentation: If possible, check for any documentation from the original seller regarding authenticity and any previous grades.
It's important to differentiate between DMPL and regular proof coins, as DMPL can often command a higher premium due to their breathtaking quality.
Enjoy the process of learning! If you have photos, feel free to share them for further feedback.
5 Likes
Thanks for the detailed response, @CoinExpert123! I really appreciate the tips. I’ll definitely look into getting it graded by PCGS or NGC. I think I might also try to take some better pictures and share them here to get some feedback. Anyone else have experiences with that, especially with uploading photos for reviews?
2 Likes
I love DMPL coins! They are truly fascinating. In addition to what @CoinExpert123 mentioned, I suggest looking at the coin’s edges as well. Any signs of tooling or re-minting? Those can definitely hint at a counterfeit. Always trust your instincts when something feels off. And remember, grading can be subjective; what one grader sees as a DMPL, another might call just a proof. Good luck!
3 Likes
Hey @CoinEnthusiast92! I’ve had a great experience sharing images for feedback. When taking photos, try to use natural light and a macro setting on your camera or phone. You want clarity in your shots so the details shine through. The community here is super helpful! Don’t hesitate to ask. 
4 Likes
Verification: Step by Step
It’s always important to be thorough with high-value coins like DMPLs. Here’s a checklist that I’ve found useful over the years:
- Determine the date and mint mark of your coin for historical context.
- Use a magnifying glass to check for the presence of scratches or hairlines that impact reflected areas.
- Research sales data for similar coins at auction to compare pricing.
- Don’t forget to check recent guides on grading from trusted sources like US Mint.
If you are new to the DMPL world, consider also reading technical grading articles to familiarize yourself with terms like
proof-like vs.
deep mirror characteristics. Every piece is different, and even subtle variances can impact value significantly!
6 Likes
Great checklist @NumismaticNerd! I’d add that just because a coin is shiny doesn’t mean it’s a DMPL. The surface quality is crucial. Many coins can appear reflective but lack the depth needed for DMPL classification. Just my two cents! 
2 Likes
Don’t forget about community resources! You can check out local coin clubs for face-to-face opinions. Often, seasoned collectors are more than willing to help verify coins. I’ve found some gems just by attending meetings!
Coin World has excellent advice, too. Their collectors’ network is vast!
3 Likes
Thanks for the tips, @SilverLover89! I’ll do my best with the photography. 
I’m excited to share my coin with everyone soon! Anyone have a favorite DMPL coin they’d like to share?
1 Like
Why don’t coins ever get lost? Because they always make cents! 
But seriously, good luck with your DMPL, @CoinEnthusiast92! Hope it’s the one you’ve been looking for!
2 Likes