Hey everyone! I recently added a beautiful 1881 Morgan Dollar to my collection, but it’s got a few bag marks that I didn’t notice initially. I was so excited to get this coin because it completes my 1880s set, but the marks have got me a bit worried. I’ve been reading up on how bag marks affect a coin’s condition and value, and there’s a lot of mixed opinions out there.
From what I understand, bag marks are pretty common for coins that circulated heavily or were stored in bulk bags, and they can definitely impact the grade. My Morgan is in decent shape otherwise, maybe a solid MS62, but I’m curious about how these marks will affect its marketability down the line. Would a collector balk at a coin with marks even if it’s otherwise attractive?
So, I’m reaching out to you all for your thoughts. Have any of you dealt with similar concerns? How do you approach these bag marks in your collections? And do you think I should be worried about this coin’s long-term value, or should I just enjoy it for what it is? Looking forward to hearing your opinions!
Hey CoinGeek95! Congratulations on your 1881 Morgan Dollar! Coin collecting is such an exciting hobby, and it’s great to hear that you’re expanding your collection. Regarding bag marks, you’re correct that they are pretty common, especially for coins that were produced in large numbers and moved around frequently.
In terms of long-term value, bag marks can certainly affect a coin’s grade and appeal, but they don’t make it worthless! If your coin is otherwise in the MS62 range, collectors will likely be more forgiving of minor marks, especially if they add character. The key factors will be the overall aesthetics and how the coin presents.
Here are a few tips to consider:
- Keep it in a protective holder.
- Make sure it’s stored in a climate-controlled environment.
- If you’re ever considering selling, have it graded by an organization like PCGS or NGC to validate its condition.
Enjoy your coin, and don’t hesitate to share pictures!
12 Likes
Thanks for the warm wishes, @SilverSeeker123! Your tips are really helpful. I’ll definitely look into getting it graded down the line. It would be nice to have a formal assessment.
5 Likes
Hi CoinGeek95! Bag marks are definitely a concern, but they shouldn’t keep you up at night! I bought a 1901-O Morgan last year with quite a few bag marks, and I was worried too. However, I found that collectors are often more interested in the rarity and overall eye appeal than the grade itself. A mint state coin like yours will still attract buyers if it’s otherwise appealing.
Just keep enjoying your collection and don’t let the marks ruin your experience. They are part of the coin’s journey!
8 Likes
Bag marks usually mean the coin has been handled, but that doesn’t mean it’s less valuable. As @CoinEnthusiast88 mentioned, it’s often about the overall presentation. If from a reputable dealer, that adds credibility as well. Just remember, each mark tells a story! Who knows what life it’s led before it reached you?
7 Likes
Interesting perspective, @NumismaticNerd! I hadn’t thought about it in terms of a coin’s story. It’s nice to think of all the hands it’s passed through before reaching my collection.
4 Likes
Hey CoinGeek95, just to add a bit on market trends, the value retention of your Morgan will largely depend on its overall demand in the market. USMint reports indicate that the Morgan Dollar remains a favorite among collectors, which bodes well for your purchase. If you maintain it well and avoid further scratches or marks, you should be in a good position in the long run!
9 Likes
Why did the coin collector break up with their girlfriend? Because she had too many bag marks! 
But seriously, as long as you love the coin and it’s a part of your collection, that’s what matters most.
15 Likes
Absolutely! I have a collection full of coins with character, and it’s sort of fun to speculate about where they’ve been. Some bag marks come from being in bags, but a few bruises here and there can add to a coin’s story! Just think twice before cleaning those marks - it can drop your grade significantly.
6 Likes
Great insights, @GoldCollectorPro! Coin valuations can be quite volatile, but the Morgan Dollar has a strong fan base. Just like you said, keep it in good shape and it’ll likely appreciate over time. Consider joining a local coin club; you might get some mentorship and insights that could benefit your collection!
7 Likes
Thanks for all the responses, everyone! It’s really reassuring to hear different viewpoints about bag marks and value. I love the idea of joining a local coin club. I’ll definitely check that out!
5 Likes