Hey everyone! So, I recently got an end roll from a friend who knows I’m a coin enthusiast, and I’m super excited about it! It’s a roll of 1964 quarters, and I can’t wait to see what’s inside. However, I’m a bit stumped on how to evaluate the overall condition of the coins without unrolling the whole thing. Anyone have tips on how to do this?
I’ve done a bit of research on grading coins and have a basic understanding of the Sheldon scale, but I’m still not sure how that translates to rolled coins. Are there any telltale signs I should look for without compromising the integrity of the roll? Personally, I’ve noticed that the paper looks fairly aged, which makes me cautious about what’s hidden within. I’d love to hear if anyone has experience with evaluating rolled coins or even specific markers to check for when assessing condition.
So, what do you all think? Have any of you dealt with similar situations? What pro tips can you share on evaluating rolled coins, particularly in terms of potential condition and value? Looking forward to your insights!
Great question, @CoinCollector42! Evaluating the condition of a rolled coin without unrolling it can be tricky, but there are a few key points you can consider.
- Visual Inspection: Check the ends of the roll. Sometimes, you can get a glimpse of the top coin or side coins which can give you a good indication of what the general condition might be.
- Paper Condition: You mentioned that the paper looks aged. This can actually be a good sign in terms of keeping the coins away from moisture, but it might also indicate that the coins have been exposed to air for a long time.
- Weight: If you have a scale, you can weigh the roll. A standard roll of quarters contains 40 coins and should weigh around 1,000 grams. If it’s significantly lighter, it might be missing coins or have damage.
Additionally, look for any visible marks on the paper that might indicate the condition of the coins inside. If you do decide to unroll it, be sure to do so very carefully to maintain the integrity of the contents. Best of luck!
Check out more on coin grading here.
5 Likes
Thanks for the detailed advice, @CoinExpertJoe! I hadn’t thought about weighing the roll. I’ll definitely give that a try.
I also noticed some discoloration on the ends, which makes me wonder if they’re worth anything. I’m just so anxious to see what’s inside without ruining it!
2 Likes
Another tip! If you have a strong flashlight, try shining it through the roll (not too close). This can sometimes allow you to see the edges of the coins inside without having to unroll it. It can give you a hint about the luster and overall toning of the coins. Also, always consider taking photos of the roll as it is before you potentially damage it. You might want to assess the value later! @CoinCollector42, keep us posted on what you find!
3 Likes
That’s a great idea, @NerdyNumismatist! I’ll definitely try the flashlight method. I hope they’re in good shape! I really got lucky with my friend giving them to me.
1 Like
If you’re looking for specific markers, look out for any rust. Particularly those nasty little spots can be a dead giveaway of moisture damage. Even if the roll looks fine from the outside, the coins inside may be affected. Make sure to inspect thoroughly if you decide to unroll them!
4 Likes
Good point, @SilverHound. I’ll keep that in mind. Rust would definitely lower the value significantly. I’ll be more careful now and look for those telltale signs.
It’s really exciting! But don’t forget that some coins may not have the best finish after so long. I once opened a roll of 1964 quarters, and to my surprise, some were in pretty good shape while others had noticeable dings and scratches. Just be ready for any surprises, both good and bad!
2 Likes
To add onto what @CollectorGal said, remember that cleaned coins can often be less valuable. If you see shiny coins inside, they may have been polished or cleaned, which can significantly lessen their value. Maintenance is key!
3 Likes
Thanks for the heads-up, @CoinWizard! I’ll definitely keep an eye out for those shiny coins. I’ve read that cleaning can drastically reduce the value. I hope I find some nice uncirculated ones!
1 Like
Don’t worry, @CoinCollector42! You could turn out to be sitting on a hidden treasure! If you’re really lucky, you may uncover some double die varieties in those rolls. Just Google ‘1964 quarter double die’ to check out what to look for! Who knows what you may find?
4 Likes
Why did the coin collector bring a ladder? Because they wanted to reach new heights! 
But really, I hope you find some amazing coins, @CoinCollector42! Don’t forget to share your finds with us!
2 Likes