Hey fellow collectors! I hope you’re all doing well. Lately, I’ve been looking at a few lower-grade coins in my collection, and I can’t help but wonder if cracking them out of their holders might yield better grades. I’ve got a couple of them that are in the VG to F range, and after some research, I learned that it’s definitely a gamble but can sometimes pay off.
I’ve seen some threads where folks have discussed the risks—potential damage to the coin during the process and how experts often say it’s not worth the trouble if you’re not confident in your submission. I’m quite meticulous when it comes to handling coins, but still, the thought of that potential does worry me a bit. I’ve also noticed how subtle cleaning issues can affect grades significantly. At the same time, I’ve read up on others who successfully upgraded their pieces and am eager to hear if anyone here has had similar experiences.
So, my question is, what tips do you have for cracking out coins? How do you assess whether it’s worth it? Have any of you regretted cracking a coin post-transaction? I’d love to hear your insights and maybe some personal stories about your own journeys with this!
Cracking out coins can be a risky but rewarding venture! Here are some tips based on my personal experiences over the years. First, assess the coin’s condition closely. Use a loupe to check for any hidden issues that may affect the grade post-cracking. If the coin is VG and has potential for a higher grade, it may be worth it. Next, consider your handling method—always wear cotton gloves, and avoid touching the surfaces directly. When you finally crack the holder, do it slowly and carefully to minimize scratches. It’s also crucial to document any changes you make to support your submission history. Make sure to have a solid plan for re-submission, including which grading service you’re using. Sometimes, I prefer to send them to PCGS or NGC for better resale potential. Lastly, be prepared for potential heartbreak if the grades don’t go as planned, as I’ve had my share of disappointments. Good luck, and happy collecting!
5 Likes
I recently cracked out a couple of my lower-grade coins and actually saw an upgrade in both! 
But I have to agree with Mike, it’s a delicate process. I had a 1937 Buffalo Nickle in a F12 holder that came back as an F15 after cracking. Just make sure you’re fully prepared—not just physically, but emotionally too. It’s scary opening them up! Have you made a list of coins you’re considering? It might help to prioritize the ones with the highest potential first.
3 Likes
Thanks for the detailed tips, @NumismatistMike! I definitely want to avoid any mishaps. I will look more closely at my coins before cracking them open. What do you think about practicing on a less valuable coin first? Would that help build confidence?
2 Likes
Exactly, @SilverSeeker24! It does help to practice first. I remember trying to crack a common coin, and it made the actual process much easier when I went for something valuable. Just remember, the goal is to make it out without scratching, so take your time! 
Plus, having a quiet space helps too.
1 Like
Alright guys, I’m not trying to rain on the parade, but a word of caution. I had a friend who cracked a coin only for it to come back a grade lower! That’s a reality. Sometimes factors like toning or other issues can make or break the final grade. You really need to weigh the risks depending on the coin’s current grade. Don’t rush this decision!
2 Likes
Thanks for the warning, @CoinNerd12! It’s true; I’ve read stories like that too. It really stresses the importance of assessing a coin thoroughly before deciding to crack. I guess it could be worth paying a pro to evaluate them first. Have you heard of any reputable services?
1 Like
I’ve done quite a bit of cracking—although not all have yielded great results. I always check for slab conditions since a cracked slab could ruin the coin’s marketability. When I’d submit coins, I’d carefully check the grading company’s history on similar coins. This is crucial; especially if you want to maximize profit. I’ve had to learn the hard way which places are more lenient and which are not. Any advice on specific grading companies?
4 Likes
Thanks, @GlennCoin! Your experience is very helpful. I’ve been leaning towards PCGS and NGC as well; they seem to be the most respected in the industry. It’s interesting how grading standards can shift! Did you have a specific coin that made you realize this?
2 Likes