Hey fellow collectors! I recently scored a fantastic MS66 example for my registry set, and I’m still on cloud nine about it! It’s a 1971-S Jefferson Nickel that I’ve been hunting for quite a while. The luster is just stunning, and the detail is crisp, which made it a no-brainer for adding to my collection. But it also got me thinking about the grading process in general.
How do you all accurately assess the grading of your coins, especially when you’re considering upgrades for your registry sets? I’ve done a bit of research on different grading standards and compared several resources, like the Photograde book and online forums, but I still find it a bit challenging. I sometimes second guess myself, especially with coins in higher grades. Any tips on spotting those subtle differences that can sway a grade from MS65 to MS66?
I’d love to hear your experiences! What indicators do you focus on? And for those who have dealt with grading before, do you have any stories of upgrading or downgrading a coin that really surprised you? Looking forward to your insights!
Congratulations on your upgrade, CoinEnthusiast92! The MS66 1971-S Jefferson Nickel is a great addition to any collection. Grading can indeed be tricky, especially for high-grade coins. Here are a few tips that have helped me:
- Assess the luster: Bright, original luster is a sign of a higher grade.
- Check for contact marks: Even the slightest scratches can affect the grade.
- Pay attention to the strike quality: Coins with a sharp strike provide clearer details.
It also helps to look at similar graded coins to compare features. I actually had a 1950-D Jefferson I thought was a gem (MS67), but it came back as MS65 because of some subtle hits. Always a learning experience! It’s great to hear how others assess their coins. What do you use for comparison besides the Photograde?
Keep collecting!
4 Likes
Thanks for the tips, <@CoinGuru89>! I appreciate the insights! Luster is definitely one of those things that catches my eye. I’m thinking of getting a few more coins graded soon. Do you have any specific resources or books besides Photograde that you’d recommend?
2 Likes
One thing I’ve found particularly helpful in grading is looking for the hairlines and toning. Many people overlook the subtleties in surface imperfections. To distinguish between a high MS65 and low MS66, you have to be meticulous. Don’t forget to check out the official guides from grading services like PCGS and NGC. Their resources offer a breakdown of grading standards. It can be eye-opening!
@CoinEnthusiast92, other than the previously mentioned Photograde, I also recommend the book ‘Grading Coins by Photographs’ for visual references.
3 Likes
Ah, the age-old grading dilemma! I remember when I sent in my 1964 Kennedy half dollar and thought it was a sure MS66, only for it to come back as MS63. Talk about a letdown! I think the best advice is to look at several examples in the same grade to see the nuances. Come to think of it, what makes you think your MS66 Jefferson is a solid upgrade, @CoinEnthusiast92? Was it average compared to others fitting the same grade?
1 Like
Definitely @OldSchoolCollector! The luster and fine details were noticeably better than the other graded examples I had. I’ve been studying the market plus the coins in my local shop for some comparison. The guy there has been really helpful!
Still, I sometimes second guess myself on the grading. Anyone dealt with a particularly surprising return from a grading authority?
2 Likes
I had a 1955 penny I really thought was a solid MS66 based on the shine and cheek detail. When it came back as MS64, I was shocked! The funny thing is I found out later it had a tiny mark I completely missed. @CoinEnthusiast92, keep that in mind—it’s often the small details that can throw off the whole grading process. Check the edges too; believe me, I’ve learned this the hard way!
3 Likes
The journey of grading is so fascinating! Each coin tells a story. I recently picked up a 2001 Silver Eagle that looked beautiful but was graded only MS69 due to a tiny mark on the reverse. Those little imperfections can be the difference!
@CoinEnthusiast92, have you thought about joining a local coin club or attending shows? It can be a great way to get real-time feedback and see coins up close!
2 Likes
Great idea, @CoinBargainHunter! I’ve been meaning to check out some local coin shows; I heard they offer great educational sessions too! Any recommendations for resources or shows near me?
I’m eager to connect with fellow collectors as well!
1 Like
Coins can be a lot like my dating life: plenty of shiny ones but hard to find a real catch! Just kidding! But seriously, your luster comments remind me of that. It’s all about discerning what’s really valuable. Keep it up, @CoinEnthusiast92!
2 Likes
Don’t underestimate the value of research! Collecting coins is not just about having shiny pieces. Understanding their history can also provide you context for grading. @CoinEnthusiast92, the more you know about the coins, the better you’ll be at assessing them accurately. Plus, check out some numismatic literature for deeper insights!
3 Likes