Hey everyone! So I was going through my grandfather’s coin collection the other day, and I stumbled upon a 1942/1. I’ve read a bit about it, and I know it’s a significant overdate error for the penny collectors out there. But here’s the kicker—I’m not sure about its condition since it looks like it’s been well-loved over the years. There’s some wear and tear, but I can still make out the overdate clearly.
My big question is, do you think it’s worth getting this coin appraised? I did some research online and saw that some of them can go for a tidy sum if they’re in decent shape. Also, it seems like the market fluctuates a lot for these types of coins. Has anyone here had experience with appraisals for similar finds? I’m really curious if I should just hang onto it for sentimental reasons or if it could actually be a valuable piece of my collection.
What are your thoughts? Should I get it appraised, or would it be better to keep it as a cherished family heirloom? I’d love to hear your experiences with error coins and appraisals!
Congratulations on your find! The 1942/1 is definitely one of those coins that excite collectors, especially when it comes to error coins. I own a few overdate pieces, and I can tell you that their value can vary drastically based on condition. Since you mentioned your coin shows wear, its grade will play a huge role in its appraised value. I’ve seen 1942/1s sell at auctions ranging from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on the state of the coin.
- Consider having it graded by a reputable service like PCGS.
- Check completed sales on NGC for a sense of value.
- Also, remember to handle it properly—use gloves to avoid any further wear!
Ultimately, it could be both a financial asset and a sentimental treasure. I’d lean towards getting it appraised. Good luck!
12 Likes
I’m a big fan of error coins too! I once found a 1955 double die in my dad’s collection, and getting it appraised changed my whole perspective. You mentioned your coin is a bit worn, but since you can make out the overdate clearly, I think that’s a positive sign. I recommend getting a couple of different opinions. Condition is key for these types of coins, and some appraisers may value it differently. Plus, who doesn’t love a little coin drama in their life? 
8 Likes
Thanks for the detailed response, @HistoryBuff77! I really appreciate the advice. I’ll definitely look into getting it graded by PCGS, as I’ve heard good things about them. The last thing I want to do is mishandle it. It’s tricky balancing the sentimental value with potential financial gain!
5 Likes
Definitely get it appraised! I had a similar experience with a 1909-S V.D.B. penny, and I was shocked at its value in decent condition. Just a heads up, early autumn tends to bring more serious bidders to auctions, so it might be a good time to consider selling if you choose that route! @CoinHunter92, remember that even if it isn’t worth a fortune, it could hold more sentimental value than any dollar amount could express.
7 Likes
Don’t underestimate sentimental value! I have a 1942/1 too, and it was given to me by my grandfather. I almost sold it once, but I realized the history behind it meant so much more than the money I could get. Yet, if you’re pondering appraisal and potential sale, keep in mind that the market for error coins can be volatile. Maybe consider a local coin show where you can get a quick assessment? That way, you get to enjoy the community too!
4 Likes
Great point, @OldCoinDude! I hadn’t thought about attending a coin show. It would be awesome to connect with other collectors and see some valuable pieces in person. I think I will explore that option as well!
3 Likes
Just another opinion on the appraisal—you can also try online estimates, but be careful! I used CoinTalk to get some opinions once and was overwhelmed with responses. Just be cautious and ensure you choose advisers who know their stuff! Happy collecting! 
5 Likes
A coin show could definitely be an adventure! You might run into some experts who could offer insight or even make an offer. Plus, it’s a great way to meet fellow enthusiasts. You can never have too many coin buddies in this hobby! @CoinHunter92, I think you’ll enjoy the experience!
4 Likes
An interesting find for sure! Just to add some humour, if it were me, I’d want to get an appraisal just to make sure I’m not sitting on a goldmine or just a really shiny rusty penny! 
But in all seriousness, keep it safe while deciding what to do! Good luck! 
2 Likes
One last thought! If you do decide to get it appraised, try to give a detailed description of its condition. Also, bring any paperwork or documentation about its history if you have it. These factors can immensely affect its value. Here’s a handy guide on grading from NGC that might help you out. Best of luck with your find!
6 Likes