Hey fellow collectors! I’m super excited to share that I just cracked out my first coin—a 1923 Peace Dollar. It was in an NGC holder, but I really wanted to give it a new look. The surface is beautiful, with just a few light scratches, but I’m unsure how to grade it now that it’s free from its plastic prison.
I’ve done some research online and I’ve seen different opinions on grade ranges for coins with slight imperfections. I’d love to hear from you all—what’s your process for reassessing a coin’s grade? How do you handle those pesky scratches or any other minor flaws? Also, how do environmental factors play into the values we assign?
I’m really curious about what kind of resources you use for grading—do you have any go-to guides, websites, or even grading techniques you’ve found helpful? Looking forward to your tips and tricks!
Congrats on your first crack-out! The 1923 Peace Dollar is a beauty! Assessing a coin’s new grade can be a bit tricky, especially after removing it from its original holder. Here are some tips that I’ve found helpful over the years:
- Examine the surface: Use a loupe to inspect for scratches, hairlines, and other imperfections.
- Light reflection: Hold the coin under a bright light to see how it interacts with the light. This will help in identifying the scratches better.
- Compare with graded examples: Look up the coin on sites like NGC or PCGS to compare with other graded 1923 Peace Dollars.
Typically, slight imperfections can lower the grade by one or two points. Good luck with your assessment!
5 Likes
Thanks, @SilverDude92! That’s really helpful. I’ll definitely take a closer look under different lighting. I didn’t think about comparing it to graded examples—great tip!
3 Likes
Great job on the crack-out! I remember the excitement when I did my first one. Scratches can be tricky, but something that often helps is to assess the overall eye appeal. If the surface has only a few light scratches but otherwise looks stunning, you might still get a decent grade! Consider using a grading guide or flipping through resources like the Bowers & Merena book for visual references to help you out.
4 Likes
Thanks, @CollectingWizard! I’ll look into that resource! I’m finding this process both thrilling and nerve-wracking.
2 Likes
If you want an objective opinion, consider posting clear, high-resolution pictures of the coin. The community is usually pretty good at offering feedback on grades, and you’ll get a variety of perspectives. Plus, we love seeing shiny coins! Just be ready for differing opinions! 
6 Likes
Totally agree, @NumismaticNerd! Sharing photos can be a great way to engage the community. Just be sure to light it well—lighting can make a huge difference in how the coin appears!
4 Likes
It’s so fun to reassess a coin’s grade! One thing you might not have considered is how environmental factors like humidity or temperature can impact a coin’s appearance over time. Make sure to keep your collection stored in a suitable environment like the Wizard Coin Protection guide. Protecting it now is as important as grading it correctly!
5 Likes
Great point, @CoinGuru99! I hadn’t thought about that. I’ll definitely look into the right storage methods—I want to keep this coin in great shape. Thanks!
2 Likes
This is exciting! It’s like opening a surprise gift. Just make sure you avoid touching the surface with your fingers—oils can really mess up the finish! I can’t wait to see how it grades! 
3 Likes
Haha, @PennyWiseCracker! Totally agree! Just think of it as giving it an upgrade. And I also find it funny how some folks have a specific number they assign to their coins while others are just like, “eh, it’s shiny!” 
4 Likes
When it comes to grading, here’s a solid process:
- Check for dirt and grime before grading.
- Use a microscope if possible for finer details.
- Consider the luster—brilliant uncirculated coins should have that reflective quality.
Always remember, the experience can be subjective, and grading can fluctuate depending on who’s assessing! Best of luck,
@CoinQuestor88!
3 Likes
Awesome, @GradingMaster77! Those tips are super detailed! I’ll make sure to check the luster and fine details carefully. What do you think the ideal grade range might be for a coin with light scratches?
2 Likes
For light scratches, I’d say you might be looking at a range of AU-58 to MS-62, depending on overall appeal. If the scratches are really minor and don’t detract significantly from the coin’s aesthetic, you could be lucky enough to hit an MS-63. Just keep in mind how those scratches interact with the light as you assess it. Good luck!
5 Likes
That gives me a good idea, @GradingMaster77! I appreciate your insight; it really helps to have a range to work from. Can’t wait to keep the discussion going!
2 Likes