Hey fellow collectors! So, I just pulled the trigger on a D over S coin that I’ve been eyeing for a while. The price seemed decent, but now that it’s done and dusted, I’m having some second thoughts. It’s a 1937-S quarter, and although it’s listed as UNC with some nice luster, I can’t shake the feeling that I might’ve overpaid.
Before making the purchase, I spent a good amount of time diving into different forums and resource sites, trying to gauge the market for this particular error coin. I came across several examples selling at varying prices based on their condition, but with the dealer being somewhat new to me, I’m now wondering about their grading and authenticity standards. Has anyone else had experiences with sellers that left them a bit uneasy after the sale?
I’d love to hear your stories about mixed feelings after a purchase. What criteria do you all base your decisions on? Also, how do you usually follow up if something doesn’t feel right? Looking forward to learning from your experiences!
Hey @CoinWizard94! I totally get where you’re coming from. Buying a coin online, especially something as unique as a D over S, can really leave you second-guessing your decision. I had a similar experience with a 1927-D St. Gaudens I bought a while back. The seller promised it was graded as MS-65, but when I received it, I suspected the grading was off. Coin grading can be subjective, especially with new dealers. I ended up sending it to PCGS for verification, which was a big relief when it came back with a good grade. They say trust but verify, right? In the end, if you’re feeling uneasy, getting a second opinion is always a smart move. Good luck!
5 Likes
Thanks for sharing that, @SilverHunter88! I think I might need to have it graded professionally too, just to ease my mind. It’s helpful to hear how others have navigated similar situations. I appreciate your insight on the verification process! Trust but verify definitely rings true for me now.
2 Likes
I understand the concern, @CoinWizard94! The D over S coins can be tricky. Prices can fluctuate significantly based on the coin’s condition and market demand.
- First, double-check the seller’s ratings and reviews.
- Then, compare prices from other sources like PCGS or NGC.
- If the deal feels off, don’t hesitate to reach out to the seller for clarification.
I’ve even had a seller agree to a return when I raised concerns about authenticity, so it’s worth asking!
3 Likes
Authenticity is key! If that D over S coin is authentic, it’s a fantastic piece. I bought a similar quarter last year and was worried because I bought from a relatively new dealer too. Just remember that prices can vary widely based on location and rarity. You’re not alone in your feelings. My biggest regret was not doing thorough research beforehand. It might be helpful to connect with your local coin club, as they often have resources to verify coins.
4 Likes
Yeah, that anxious feeling is real! I bought a high-grade Lincoln penny once and felt sick for days about whether I overpaid. I reached out to a few experienced collectors I knew, and they helped me feel better about my decision. Just remember that sometimes it’s also about the joy of the hunt. If you love the piece, it might just be worth the price, regardless of market value!
2 Likes
Something to keep in mind, @CoinWizard94, is that while online purchases can feel risky, every collector faces this at some point. I usually base my decision on three main criteria:
- Condition of the coin
- Reputation of the seller
- Actual market value I’ve researched
Also, if you’re ever unsure post-purchase, don’t hesitate to reach out to the dealer. It shows you’re knowledgeable and passionate about your collection!
3 Likes
I appreciate all the tips! @CollectorChick, having a checklist sounds like a solid strategy. I might take the plunge and get my coin graded - I just want to make sure I’m making wise investments.
1 Like
Oh, the D over S! It can be a fantastic find if you get the right one! I think it’s crucial to remember that each coin has its story. My friend found a D over S at a flea market, and he almost didn’t buy it because the seller seemed shady. Turns out, it was a keeper and worth way more than he paid! Just keep your eyes peeled and do your research. You never know where you’ll find gems!
2 Likes
Sounds familiar! I once bought a coin off a social media site that I later found out was counterfeit. It was a painful lesson but also made me much more cautious when buying online. Always ask for provenance documents if they’re offered, and don’t be shy about requesting detailed images from sellers. Good luck, @CoinWizard94 – you can always salvage your collection if you make informed choices! 
3 Likes
In supporting @CoinWizard94 – if your gut is telling you something’s off, it’s worth investigating further. I actually walked away from a deal once because the seller couldn’t prove the coin’s authenticity, and I ended up finding a much better deal later on. Trust your intuition! As collectors, we’re often too eager to complete our sets, but patience is key.
5 Likes