Hey everyone! I recently came across a small stash of coins that I’m pretty sure fall into the Mint State (MS) category. I’ve been doing some research, but I’m wondering how to effectively use the PCGS Photograde to assess their condition. I’m aware that even minor imperfections can change a coin’s grade, and I want to be thorough in my evaluation.
I’ve checked a few of the coins under magnification and noticed some minor contact marks that could affect their grade, but overall, the luster and strike seem impressive. I’m particularly curious about how others interpret the photos in the Photograde guide. Sometimes, I feel like I’m overthinking it! Have any of you had success using it? What specific details do you look for when comparing your coins?
I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences! Any tips on honing in on the subtle differences between MS63 and MS65, for instance? Looking forward to our discussion!
Using PCGS Photograde was a game-changer for me! When I first got into coin collecting, I struggled to differentiate between various Mint State grades, especially MS63 and MS65. Here’s how I assess my coins using Photograde:
- Lighting: Natural light is key when examining coins. I find that using a lightbox improves the visibility of luster and any imperfections.
- Surface Examination: Begin with basic observations—make sure to zoom in on the coin's surface using a magnifier. For MS grades, I look for the presence of contact marks and scratches. They can sometimes be subtle but crucial.
- Luster: This is critical! Coins in the MS range will have a full, original luster that’s bright and reflective. Compare your coin to the Photograde examples and look for dullness or less than perfect surfaces.
- Strike Quality: MS coins should exhibit sharp detail—check the high points for wear or softness.
It's also helpful to have a few known grade coins on hand to compare side-to-side. You might find that understanding the differences visually becomes easier with experience. I encourage you to take your time, as it's easy to feel overwhelmed but rewarding to learn the nuances. Happy collecting!
12 Likes
Thanks for the detailed breakdown, @CoinExpert101! I really appreciate the tips on lighting and surface examination. I’ll definitely try to compare my coins directly to examples in the guide. It makes sense to have a few known grades for reference, too! Just out of curiosity, did you notice an improvement in your grading accuracy over time?
5 Likes
Absolutely, @CoinExpert101! I’ve had a similar experience! The most critical thing for me is understanding the difference between MS63 and MS65. The jump in value can be steep, so I pay close attention to the tiniest marks. Sometimes it’s those micro-scratches that are hardly visible but can make a big difference in price. Also, don’t hesitate to post pictures to get community feedback if you’re unsure!
8 Likes
Hey @CoinHunter22! I completely understand the anxiety about grading. I tend to feel that I overthink it as well, especially after investing in coins. Remember, the grade can often be subjective. Look closely at the overall aesthetic of the coin, too—sometimes it’s not just about the minute details but how the whole piece presents itself. If you have specific coins in mind, feel free to share some photos! Also, have you checked out PCGS Photograde yet? They have great resources!
4 Likes
Thanks, @CoinCollector88! I’ve been really focused on the details, but you’re right about overall presentation being important too. I’ll definitely take a look at the PCGS Photograde link you shared! I also plan to post some coins later for everyone’s input. Cheers!
3 Likes
One thing I love about the PCGS Photograde is the side-by-side comparison. You can see differences in gradation more effectively. You might find that having a few ungraded coins can help too. Over time, you learn to spot tell-tale signs that set certain grades apart. Just don’t forget to enjoy the process as well! It’s not all about the grades; it’s the journey of collecting!
7 Likes
Couldn’t agree more, @SilverSleuth! I often find myself sneaking a snack while checking my collection! 
It’s always about that personal connection with the coins. The grading just comes as a bonus! Have fun and let us know what you uncover!
9 Likes
For sure, @Numismatic_Nerd! It took me a good couple of months, but I’ve become much more confident. Just remember, practice makes perfect, and don’t hesitate to ask for second opinions!
5 Likes
Remember: taking breaks can help reset your brain when you’re stuck overanalyzing! I use a timer if I’m examining for too long, then I step back and come back fresh. That way, I see things I missed before!
It’s a good technique if you find yourself too stressed—let the brain rest and ponder!
2 Likes