Hey everyone! So, I was sifting through my collection the other day, and I stumbled upon a 1916 Mercury dime that has a privy mark that looks off to me. The mark appears way off-center and is not what I would typically expect for that year. I’ve been researching for hours, but it’s hard to find concrete info on errors unless they’re extremely well-known.
I’m really curious whether anyone else has experienced something similar with privy marks—especially on dimes or similar coins! My Mercury dime is in XF condition, with some nice luster, so I’m just wondering if I should get it graded or keep it as is. Is it more valuable with the potential error? Honestly, I’m torn about whether to pursue this further or just let it be a quirky addition to my collection.
Have any of you seen unusual privy marks before? What did you do with them? I’m really keen to hear your thoughts and experiences!
Hi @CoinHobbyist87! I understand your dilemma about that 1916 Mercury dime. It’s not uncommon to find privy marks that appear unusual. In my experience, I once found a 1910 dime with an off-center privy mark that had me questioning its authenticity. After consulting with experts, I decided to send it to PCGS for grading, and it turned out to be a rare variety which elevated its value significantly.
Here’s what I recommend you consider:
- Research: Keep digging into articles or forums dedicated to mint errors. You’d be surprised how many collectors have encountered similar pieces.
- Grading: Since your coin is in XF condition, having it graded could provide a clearer picture of its market value.
- Community Input: Posting clear images of the coin on this forum or others might attract feedback from enthusiasts who specialize in privy marks.
Good luck! Can’t wait to hear what you decide to do!
7 Likes
Thanks for the insights, @CoinCollectorGuru! That’s encouraging to hear. I’ll definitely look into getting it graded, especially since it sounds like there’s a chance it might be more valuable than I thought. I’ll post some pictures soon so the community can weigh in. Really appreciate your advice!
3 Likes
Hey @CoinHobbyist87! Privy marks can indeed be tricky. I found a 1921 penny once that had a similar off-center mark, and it turned out that it was a known error. After I got it graded, it was valued much higher. Mercury dimes can fetch great interest, especially in better grades. If you’re torn, judging market interest can help; perhaps check recent auction results for similar coins. 
5 Likes
Privy marks specifically can have a profound impact on the coin’s value if verified as a mint error. I’d recommend sending it to a credible grading service like NGC. Also, consider documenting the coin’s details extensively. It’ll make the evaluation easier.
4 Likes
@NumismaticNerd99, I appreciate your input! It seems like getting it graded is the most logical step. I’ll take a moment to browse auction sites for comparables—definitely a good idea. Thanks again!
2 Likes
Hey everyone! I’ve dealt with privy marks before. One time I found a coin with a privy mark that seemed altered. I ended up displaying it alongside my other interesting pieces rather than going through the grading process. Sometimes, quirky finds can make your collection more fun! Just a thought! 
6 Likes
@CollectorJoe, that’s a valid point! Sometimes the character a coin adds to a collection can outweigh its financial worth. I might consider holding onto mine as a conversation starter too! Thanks for sharing your experience.
3 Likes
I collected a few errors in my days; it’s all part of the fun! My favorite was a 1937 Washington quarter with an odd privy mark. Definitely get it authenticated if you’re unsure! The community’s feedback is invaluable, good luck!
4 Likes
Privy marks can be tricky! Some are natural errors while others are counterfeit attempts. If I were you, I’d check with a reputable grading service like US Mint for their insights on your specific case. Once graded, you’ll know more about that coin’s true value! Good luck!
5 Likes
Thanks for the tip, @ErrorCoinHunter! I’ll definitely reach out to those professional services you’ve mentioned. Getting a second opinion could provide the clarity I need. Appreciate all the help!
I like the idea of embracing quirky finds, @CollectorJoe! It makes for great stories! I once had a dime that looked more like a donut than a coin! 
Just keep it light, but seriously, your collection should reflect your personality!
8 Likes