Hey everyone! I recently stumbled upon a population report that features a certain variety of my favorite coin, the 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln penny. As a long-time collector, I was pretty excited, but now I’m on a quest to confirm the attribution and understand what steps I can take to ensure it stands out in my collection.
I’ve done some research on the different markers that distinguish this variety — I even pulled out my magnifying glass to compare my specimen with the images I found online. It seems my coin is in pretty decent condition, likely a fine or very fine grade, but I want to make sure before I get it officially graded. Has anyone here had success with attributing similar varieties? What are the best resources or references you’ve used? I’ve also read about how proper documentation can really boost a coin’s value, so I’m curious if specific grading companies are preferred for this variety.
I’d love to hear your thoughts! What would you recommend as a good first step in authenticating my coin? Any tips on how to navigate the grading process? Looking forward to your insights!
Hey CoinGuru123! It’s awesome that you found a population report for the 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln penny. To confirm its attribution, I recommend a two-pronged approach. First, thoroughly compare the details, such as the positioning of the mintmark and die marks, against the references available on PCGS or NGC. These sites provide guides and comparison images that can be super helpful for validating your coin.
Second, you might want to consider reaching out to a local coin club for assistance. Many collectors are eager to help, and you might find someone who has experience with this specific variety. They can provide firsthand insights that you may not find in books or online. Good luck with your coin, and remember that condition really matters—make sure to handle it gently!
Lastly, once you do get it graded, ensure to keep all documentation, as it significantly helps with the coin’s value. I’m looking forward to hearing how it goes!
5 Likes
Thanks for the detailed advice, CoinExpert99! I hadn’t thought about reaching out to local clubs—that’s a great idea. I’ll definitely check out the guides on PCGS and NGC. I really want to make sure I’m confirming the right markers. Do you have any suggestions for specific clubs or online communities?
Also, would it be worth trying to get a second opinion after the initial grading? I’ve heard mixed opinions about that process.
2 Likes
Hi there! I’ve collected the 1909-S V.D.B. for years and can tell you confidently that the key to attribution lies in the die markers. Make sure to examine the following:
- Location and size of the mintmark
- Letter spacing in 'V.D.B.'
- External die scratches
When I compared mine with photos online, it was super enlightening. Also, once you get the grade, proper documentation can seriously pump up your coin's value.
I suggest using US Mint's resources too, as they offer a wealth of background information on various coin types.
3 Likes
You’re spot on, @PennyCollector88! Those die markers are crucial. It’s amazing how just a small detail can confirm a coin’s identity. Also, regarding re-grading: some collectors do it to ensure they’re getting the best market price, especially with higher-value coins. But be cautious: grading fees can add up. If your first submission comes back as high-grade, it might not be worth it unless you think there’s a significant bump in value. Just my two cents!
4 Likes
Great thread! As a long-time collector, I’ve learned that each coin has a story. If that 1909-S V.D.B. has a great backstory or unique provenance, it can really increase its value as well. Consider documenting any known history behind your coin. If you’ve inherited it or found it, keep track of that! I remember finding one in a roll and still feel thrilled when I think about its journey.
Here’s a tip: consider using a reputable grading service like NGC or PCGS. They’ve built trust in the community for a reason.
2 Likes
That’s a good point, @OldCoinSage! I’ll definitely keep a record of any history. It adds a personal value too. Do you think certain backstories resonate more with buyers? I’d hate to miss out simply because I didn’t mention something important. And thank you for the reassurance on those grading services!
1 Like
Lol! I can’t help but smile at the excitement in this thread! Remember: everyone can stumble upon coin varieties. Just like my neighbor found a 1916-D Merc in a random box! So keep hunting! And don’t be afraid to show off your coin when you get it graded—everyone loves a good story or a rare find.
3 Likes
Absolutely, CoinGuru123! Backstories can definitely tug at buyers’ heartstrings. Try to include any connections the coin has—like when it was minted or a family tie if applicable. Some collectors love that human element. It adds depth!
Also, grading can sometimes open doors to auctions where buyers appreciate not just the coin, but its narrative too. It’s all part of the collecting experience!
2 Likes
Just wanted to chime in! I think you’re on the right track, @CoinGuru123. Grading is so important. I once had a 1894-S Barber dime that I was sure was in great condition, but I ended up getting a lower grade than I expected. Lesson learned: don’t underestimate the grading process!
So ensure you look closely at your coin and perhaps even consult more than one grader if you’re unsure. Sometimes they differ in opinions!
4 Likes
Thanks for sharing that experience, @CuriousChris! It’s good to know I should consider multiple opinions if needed. I’m excited but also a bit nervous about the grading process. 
Just hope it comes back better than expected!
Any tips for preparing my coin for grading? I want to make sure I do everything right.
3 Likes