Hey fellow collectors! I recently came across what I believe might be a doubled die error coin while sifting through some of my grandfather’s old collections. It’s a 1955 Lincoln penny, and I’m torn about its grade. The doubling is quite pronounced, especially on the ‘Liberty’ and ‘In God We Trust’ inscriptions, but the surface has some light scratches and a bit of tarnish.
Now, I’m trying to pin down its condition to figure out if it’s worth sending in for grading. I’ve done some research and know that the criteria like luster, scratches, and the clarity of the doubling play huge roles in determining value. However, grading can feel quite subjective sometimes. Have you guys found effective methods to assess condition—like using a loupe or comparing it against high-quality online images?
I’d love to hear your tips! What’s your experience with grading doubled die coins? Any specific resources or grading standards you rely on? Let’s dive into this together!
Grading a doubled die coin can definitely be a challenge, especially with a prized piece like a 1955 Lincoln penny! Here’s how I approach it:
- Luster: Check if the original luster is still present. A coin that has lost its shine can drop a grade significantly.
- Surface marks: Light scratches can sometimes be overlooked, but deep scratches or gouges can detract from the value.
- Doubling clarity: The more pronounced the doubling is, the higher its potential value. Make sure it's not just wear affecting the doubling effect.
- Comparison: Use high-resolution images of graded coins from resources like PCGS or NGC for reference.
Additionally, using a good quality loupe (at least 10x magnification) can really help you see details that aren't visible to the naked eye. I’ve had good luck grading through the years by employing these techniques. Let us know how it goes and feel free to share photos!
5 Likes
Thanks for the detailed response, @CoinCollector78! I really appreciate the breakdown of luster and surface marks. I’ll definitely invest in a loupe if I decide to go forward with grading. Do you recommend any particular brand or model?
2 Likes
Regarding your 1955 Lincoln penny, the best way to ensure an accurate grade is to consider both the visual and tactile aspects. Always check for:
- Worn relief: Look closely at the finer details—not just the doubling, but also areas that typically wear away faster.
- Patina: A tarnished surface can sometimes obscure important features. See if it can be cleaned gently, but be careful!
- Expert opinions: If you're unsure, don't hesitate to ask experienced collectors in the community or consult professional graders.
If you suspect it's a significant doubling error, sending it to a mint or grading service like
US Mint for verification may be worth it. Good luck!
3 Likes
I’ve found that the Belomo 10x loupe works wonders! Good lens quality, and it’s affordable. Just make sure it has a light for shadowy areas. You can usually find it online for about $20–$30.
1 Like
Grading can indeed feel subjective! I had a similar experience with a 1969-S doubled die and it turned out to be worth a small fortune! Just be honest about the condition when you evaluate it. Also keep an eye out on eBay and auction sites for similar pieces with their grades listed—it helps to have a frame of reference.
4 Likes
That’s a great shout, @SilverSeeker101! I also think comparing auction prices can offer useful insights. Also, don’t underestimate the power of community! Sometimes, just showing your coin in a forum can lead to unexpected advice or interest from collectors.
3 Likes
Don’t forget about the overall eye appeal! A coin’s aesthetic quality can elevate its appeal amongst collectors, sometimes more than technical grades. The 1955 Lincoln penny has historical significance too, which might enhance its market value. Remember, if you’re unsure, consulting articles on NGC’s education page can clarify a lot.
2 Likes
Thanks for the tip, @RareCoinGuru! I hadn’t considered eye appeal in depth. I’ll definitely check out the NGC education page for more insights. It seems like this penny may have a story of its own!
1 Like
Good luck with your grading, @CoinWizard55! Always remember, we can’t take coins too seriously. They’re fun pieces of history, and some light-hearted joking can relieve the stress of grading. Just recently, I jokingly said my penny went on a ‘spa day’ after I polished it. It sounds silly, but keep the fun alive!
5 Likes