Hey fellow collectors! I recently came across a clipped planchet in my collection from a recent local coin show. It’s a 1953 penny with a noticeable clip at the edge, and I was thrilled when I spotted it. It made me wonder about how often these little anomalies pop up in our collections. Does anyone else have a story about finding a clipped planchet?
I’ve done a bit of digging, and from what I understand, clipped planchets are generally considered errors that can really add character to a collection. However, I’m still trying to wrap my head around the rarity and potential value. I know not all clipped coins are created equal; it seems like the more extreme the clip, the more interesting—and valuable—they become. I wonder if there’s a threshold for what collectors typically seek.
I’d love to hear your thoughts! Have you ever valued a clipped planchet differently than a regular coin? How does the condition of the clip influence how you perceive its worth? Let’s share our experiences and maybe even some photos of our finds!
Great find, CoinHunter92! Clipped planchets are indeed fascinating pieces of numismatic history. I found a 1944 nickle with a clipped edge at a flea market once. It wasn’t in perfect condition, but the clip made it unique! Coins like these can vary significantly in value based on several factors. For instance, the size and severity of the clip, the type of coin, and the overall grade can all impact worth. I’ve seen clipped coins from the 1950s sell anywhere from a few dollars to over a hundred, depending on those factors.
Rarity: They can be rare, especially if the error is prominent.
Market Trends: Current market demand also plays a role.
Documentation: Having third-party grading helps in establishing the coin’s value.
You might want to check NGC for their grading guidelines on error coins. Here’s a link to their error section: NGC Error Coins. Let me know if you have questions!
Thanks, @NumismatistGary! That’s really interesting! I didn’t realize the value could vary so much. Would you say the condition of the coin overall influences the value more than the clip itself?
I actually just purchased a clipped planchet too! It’s a 1960 dime with a noticeable clip on the edge, and I got it for only $15. For me, it adds a fun story to my collection. I think the unique designs and errors are what make coin collecting so enjoyable! How does your 1953 penny look, CoinHunter92? Any pictures?
To answer your question, CoinHunter92, yes! The overall condition of the coin absolutely plays a vital role in its valuation. Even if the clip is significant, a rusty or heavily worn coin might not fetch much. In my experience:
Less than Good (G): Not worth much, even with a major clip.
Fine (F) to Very Fine (VF): You could see decent interest—especially if the clip is distinct.
AU or better: These tend to command the best prices when coupled with a sharp clip.
Each collector has their preferences, of course. More extreme clips certainly attract attention! If interested, PCGS has some valuable articles on error coins that may help you gauge your penny’s worth.
Exactly, @CoinExpertLisa! Errors are subjective. What one collector finds valuable, another might see as a simple oddity. I’d love to hear more about your findings, CoinHunter92!
Thanks for the insights, @NumismatistGary and @CoinExpertLisa! Here’s a picture of my 1953 penny: . It has a pretty clear clip on the edge. I’m excited to see what you all think!
Clipped planchets can be so fun! I remember the first one I found. It was in a roll of coins from my grandma’s house. Turns out, it was a 1971 quarter. Not super rare, but oddly enough I cherish it because it reminds me of her. Not everything is about value. That sentimental aspect is often overlooked in our hobby.
That’s a great perspective, @OldSchoolNumis. I totally agree that the stories behind our coins can make them invaluable. Kind of like each coin has a soul, you know? Thanks for sharing!
Absolutely! It’s those memories linked to the coins that enhance our collections! I sometimes joke with friends that the rarest coins I own are the ones with epic stories behind them.