Hey fellow collectors! I recently stumbled upon a West Point quarter from 2019 that has a striking error—specifically, a double die obverse. After doing some research online, I found out that these error coins can dramatically increase in value compared to their standard counterparts. They add a unique layer of excitement to our collections, don’t you think?
I’m curious about your experiences! Have any of you discovered West Point coins with noticeable errors? For this particular quarter, I found it in an MS64 condition, but some similar coins online are listed anywhere from $60 to over $150, depending on the error’s visibility and collector interest. It got me thinking about how error coins can fluctuate in market value based on supply, demand, and the community’s inclination to cherish these anomalies.
What do you think makes error coins so appealing? Have you noticed any trends in the market lately? I’d love to hear about your finds and any tales of extraordinary West Point errors you’ve encountered. Let’s chat!
I can definitely relate to your excitement, CoinCollector89! I stumbled upon a West Point nickel with a significant error—a misaligned die strike. I had it graded at MS65, and to my surprise, it fetched around $200! It seems that the more unique the error, the higher the value goes.
- Rare varieties and error types
- Grading condition
- Market demand
All of these factors really play into the final price. I think collectors love error coins not only for their rarity but also for the history they represent!
5 Likes
Thanks for sharing your find! It’s incredible how error coins can lead to such different values. Could you tell me more about how you verified the misalignment?
2 Likes
I totally agree that error coins add excitement! I recently got my hands on a West Point quarter with an off-center strike. After some research, I found that similar pieces sell for around $75-$120, depending on grading. Collectors seem to appreciate the oddities, possibly because they feel like a hidden treasure in our collections.
3 Likes
I’ve seen similar coins too! What’s fascinating is that the error’s visibility and collector interest can shift the value so dramatically. Does anyone else keep track of market trends like that? I love checking out sites like PCGS or NGC for updates on the latest sales.
4 Likes
Absolutely, CoinCollector89! I took it to a local coin shop, where they have experienced appraisers. They highlighted how to look for alignment using a loupe and compared it with similar graded coins for reference. It was eye-opening! Always good to have a second opinion.
2 Likes
You all bring up awesome points! Error coins are a way of connecting with the makers of the coin. It’s a tangible piece of history, a reminder of the minting process. They just seem to tell a story. Sometimes, when I find one, I imagine the tiny mistake that made it unique. 
Besides, they often brag impressive returns in auctions!
4 Likes
I’ve been following this trend too! I think more young collectors are getting fascinated by error coins. My uncle had a double die coin, and I managed to find a similar looking piece online that was valued at around $85! It really opens up the realm of collecting for newer generations.
3 Likes
I saw your post and it’s super timely! I’ve been trying to get my hands on a West Point error coin myself! Any recommendations on how to differentiate between real errors and fakes? I want to ensure my next purchase is a worthy addition. 
3 Likes
Great question, RareFindz99! Start by researching common types of errors. Websites like US Mint are great for that. Secondly, look for reputable dealers and buy graded coins from trustworthy sources. Pay attention to the luster and the overall design of the coin—those small details can reveal a lot! Good luck!
5 Likes
Thanks, ErrorHunter42! Those tips are super helpful. I’ll make sure to look up some resources before diving into the market.
2 Likes