Hey fellow collectors! I recently got my hands on a 1916-D Mercury dime, and I’m gearing up to have it graded. This year is such a key date for the series, so I want to ensure I do everything right. The coin looks decent, but it has a couple of small scratches that make me a bit nervous. I’ve read up on grading standards, but seeing such a valuable coin in a high grade really makes me second guess everything!
I’d love to hear from anyone who’s gone through the grading process for their 1916-D. How did you prepare? Did you clean your coin at all, or did you leave it in its natural state? I’ve seen mixed opinions on whether cleaning could hurt the grade. Also, what grading service did you use, and how was your experience with them? I’m really eager to learn more from the community and would appreciate any personal insights you can share.
Looking forward to your stories and tips! Have you encountered any surprises in grading? What small details should I pay extra attention to? Can’t wait to hear your experiences!
Hey CoinCollectorJoe! I just had my 1916-D graded a few months back, and I can definitely share my experience! First off, I strongly recommend not cleaning your coin. The experts say that cleaning can significantly reduce the value and grade due to hairlines, which are really hard to spot with the naked eye. Projecting a natural appearance is crucial for a coin like this. I sent mine to NGC (National Guaranty Corporation), and they were super helpful. The process took about 3 weeks, and I received a decent MS-65 grade, which I was thrilled about. Their online submission tracking helped ease my anxiety too. If you haven’t already, check out the grading standards on NGC’s website for more guidance on what they look for. Good luck! 
15 Likes
Thanks, CoinEnthusiast88! I appreciate your insights! That’s really reassuring to hear about not cleaning it. I’ll definitely look into NGC. It’s good to know they have tracking! Did you do anything special to prepare your coin before sending it in, like checking for specific areas?
5 Likes
Hi everyone! I recently graded my 1916-D with PCGS. I’ve found that edge and surface condition are critical. I made sure to examine the details carefully and took multiple photos under different lighting. I noticed one tiny scratch that had me worried, but the graders were quite forgiving about minor imperfections. I’ve also read MS-64 is a common grade for these, so be prepared for a range. You might be lucky and get a higher grade if they overlook minor flaws like mine! Good luck with your submission!
8 Likes
Great point, SilverSeeker42! Also, make sure to check the strikes. The 1916-D is known for some really weak strikes that can influence the grade. If you have a great strike in addition to minimal scratches, you’re looking at a higher probability of a good grade. Make sure to inspect those details closely!
6 Likes
I was super nervous about my 1916-D too! I sent mine to NGC and they did a great job. Just be patient; if it’s taking longer than expected, they’re probably paying special attention to it. I agree—check the minor flaws, especially on the obverse and reverse. I ended up with an MS-64 and was relieved it wasn’t worse than I feared! Good luck!
7 Likes
Thanks for sharing, DimeDiva! It sounds like you had a similar experience! I’m really focused on examining the surfaces now. Did you find any surprises while grading, or was everything as you expected?
3 Likes
Honestly, @CoinCollectorJoe, I was surprised by how much detail they actually appreciated. I thought my scratches would really hurt but the examiners were very focused on the overall eye appeal. Just remember to be thorough but don’t stress too much about minor imperfections! 
4 Likes
Quick tip! I recommend using a soft cloth just to remove dust before sending. It’s easy to overlook, but particles can affect the result. I use a microfiber cloth for my coins, and it works just fine. Good luck with your 1916-D!
3 Likes
Thanks for the tip, CoinChaser99! I will definitely take your advice! It’s easy to forget about the cleaning aspect. I can only imagine what they might think if I sent in a dust-covered dime!
5 Likes
Here’s a fun fact! The 1916-D is not just rare, but it also has a fascinating history! It was the first year the mint produced Mercury dimes, and the mintmark was moved to the back to accommodate the design. Just remember, the story behind your coin is just as important as its grade! Don’t forget to enjoy the collecting journey! 
10 Likes
Great insights, everyone! This is so helpful as I’m also considering grading my 1916-D. Have any of you had experience with cleaning before grading? I’ve heard varying opinions, and it’s hard to be sure what to do!
3 Likes
Welcome, CuriousCollector01! Cleaning is a big no-no as it can really damage the coin’s surface. I would suggest you check with a professional or even submit it in its natural state. The grading service you choose can help guide you too if you call them! Definitely keep your coin’s originality intact!
5 Likes