Hey everyone! I recently stumbled upon a wrong planchet coin in my collection—it’s a 1943 Lincoln cent struck on a copper planchet instead of the zinc-coated steel. I was so excited to add it to my lineup, but I’ve been toying with the idea of trading it for something else that’s catching my eye. The crazy thing is, I’ve read mixed opinions on how to approach trading such rarities.
I’ve done some research on the rarity and demand for these wrong planchet coins, especially the ones from the 1940s. The condition of mine is pretty solid, with only minor wear, which I think adds to its appeal. However, I’m worried about undervaluing it or maybe not finding the right collector who appreciates it as much as I do. Has anyone here managed to trade a similar coin? What strategies did you use?
I’d love to hear your tips or any stories about trading unusual coins. How did you determine its worth and ultimately find the right trade? Let’s share some insights!
Hi CoinEnthusiast123! I love that you found a 1943 Lincoln cent on a copper planchet! Those are definitely a treasure and can be quite valuable. I’ve successfully traded several wrong planchet coins before, so I can share a few tips that might help you out.
First, it’s crucial to determine the market value of your coin. Check out resources like PCGS or NGC for recent sales and current values. Make sure to have your coin graded by a professional if it hasn’t been already; the grade can significantly affect its value.
In my experience, timing is also critical. Reach out to local coin dealers and collectors who specialize in rarities. They often appreciate and understand the value of such coins better than general collectors. Negotiate confidently, but be prepared for a counteroffer. It’s also worth considering trading in online communities or forums where more specialized collectors gather. Good luck with your trade, and let us know how it goes!
5 Likes
Thanks for the tips, CoinSavvy99! I’ll definitely check out those resources. I haven’t had my coin graded yet, but I think it’s probably in the VF range based on my research. I appreciate your advice, and I’ll keep everyone posted on my trading journey!
3 Likes
Hey CoinEnthusiast123! I had a similar experience when I found a wrong planchet coin last year. I managed to trade a 1944 steel penny on a copper planchet—a pretty cool find! Here’s what I did:
- Looked up prices and trades on forums and auction sites, emphasizing auction results.
- Advertised my coin on social media groups where other collectors hang out.
- Prepared detailed photos of the coin to showcase its condition.
I ended up trading it for a better condition 1909-S V.D.B. Lincoln penny, which I’d wanted for ages! Just be patient and don’t rush into a trade because of excitement. Good luck!
4 Likes
That’s awesome, NumismatistPaul! It’s good to hear about successful trades. I think the key is to have a solid understanding of your coin’s value and to be willing to walk away from offers you feel are too low. Coin collecting can be emotional, especially with unique finds, but staying analytical can pay off. And if you’re ever feeling uncertain, you can always reach out to local dealers for a second opinion before making a trade!
2 Likes
Hey everyone! I collect all kinds of weird coins, including wrong planchets. One time, I traded a wrong planchet quarter (wrongfully minted on a nickel planchet) for an MS-67 grade 1955-D Lincoln which, as you know, is a valuable date! Always consider the collector’s mindset: what makes your coin special and how can that benefit them? Sometimes sharing the story behind the coin can build interest and lead to a better deal. Just a thought!
3 Likes
@GoldenMintGem, that’s a great point! The story behind a coin often adds to its allure. I remember reading about how some wrong planchet coins have unique history and can sometimes attract a premium just for that reason. Keep the enthusiasm but approach trades logically. Have you ever thought about displaying your coins with their trading story? It might just add an extra layer of value!
1 Like
Does anyone here know about how much a 1943 copper penny is worth nowadays? I mean, I’ve seen all kinds of prices thrown around, but it seems so dependent on condition! What should I expect if I have one in decent shape?
@CuriousCollector42, it really does depend on the condition of the coin. From what I gathered, it can range from a few hundred dollars for lower grades to several thousand for those in mint condition. I’d recommend checking recent sales on sites like PCGS for the most accurate market reflection. I’m also excited to find out what mine might fetch once I get it graded!
2 Likes
The excitement of trading coins can be both thrilling and nerve-wracking! Just remember that sometimes you might need to let a coin go if you’re not getting the value it deserves. Trading a wrong planchet coin is especially unique! Have confidence in your knowledge of it. And hey, if nothing else, you can always keep it as a conversation starter whenever you’re showcasing your collection!
1 Like
Why did the coin collector get kicked out of the casino? Because he kept trying to trade pennies for chips! 
Seriously though, make sure you’re in a good community when you trade those rarities. The right audience can make all the difference! Good luck!
1 Like