Hey fellow collectors! I’ve been diving deep into the world of privy marks and their influence on coin valuation lately, and I’m beginning to see just how significant they can be. Recently, I picked up a 1907 Canadian Silver Dollar with a small privy mark that caught my eye. I remember thinking it was a neat little addition, but after doing some research, I was shocked to discover its value nearly doubles compared to the same coin without the mark!
It got me wondering, though—how often are we taking these marks into account when we evaluate our collections? From my experience, privy marks can indicate specific minting events or commemorate important anniversaries, which adds a rich story behind the coin. But I’m curious to know if others have seen this reflected in their experiences, too. Do you have any coins that have increased in value significantly because of a privy mark? Have you changed how you approach your collecting because of this?
I’d love to hear your thoughts on this! Do you check for privy marks every time you scope out a new piece? What other factors do you think impact coin value as much as privy marks do?
Absolutely! Privy marks can be game-changers for coin value. I first realized this when I purchased a 1908 Canadian Silver Dollar with a privy mark. Initially, I thought it was just a quirky detail, but later I found that it was linked to a specific minting error which made it highly sought after. I sold it at a coin fair last year, and I definitely got more than what I expected—even premium prices!
- It’s fascinating how these small details can tell us so much about a coin’s history.
- Have you checked out PCGS or NGC? They have some great articles on privy marks and their implications!
So yes, I’ve definitely learned to pay closer attention to privy marks when I’m evaluating coins for my collection.
11 Likes
Thanks for sharing your experience, @CoinMaster99! It’s amazing how a little mark can add so much value. I didn’t realize it could be linked to minting errors. Looks like I need to enhance my research skills for each coin! What specific resources do you use when researching privy marks?
3 Likes
I totally agree with you both! Privy marks have definitely made a difference in my own collection. I have a 1912 Canadian quarter with a privy mark commemorating the diamond jubilee of Queen Victoria, and its value shot up considerably after I discovered its significance. It’s like uncovering a hidden treasure! I check for privy marks every time I’m at a dealer or coin show now. Not to mention, it also makes for some interesting conversations!
7 Likes
It’s so true, @SilverSeeker77! Each mark tells a story. The educational aspect of collecting is one of my favorite things about it. The privy marks can often tell you when and why a coin was minted, which adds so much depth to the collection. Do you find it hard to keep track of which marks correspond to which events?
5 Likes
It’s very interesting to hear everyone’s experiences! I have been collecting for over 10 years. Privy marks have become increasingly significant in my evaluations. There’s also a psychology to it— collectors love the uniqueness and stories behind privy marks, which can create a sort of frenzy at auctions. I just bought a coin at a fraction of its perceived market value, because it had a minor privy mark that many overlooked! Just goes to show that educated collectors can find excellent deals. Has anyone had similar experiences?
9 Likes
Exactly, @RarityHunter! Just the other day I was at a local coin shop and found a 1905 nickel with a privy mark that nobody else seemed to notice! I think it’s important to do thorough due diligence before making a buy. Sometimes it’s the less obvious coins that are the real gems with massive potential.
6 Likes
Tracking privy marks can be a challenge! What I do is keep a dedicated notebook with images and explanations of each mark I find. That way, I can just flip through it when I’m considering a purchase. You might be surprised how different some coins can look with or without the privy marks. I also refer to the site US Mint for accurate info. Keeping organized is key!
5 Likes
I love this discussion! The excitement of uncovering a coin’s backstory is exhilarating. Just this week, I found a rare 1945 penny with a privy mark, and I was ecstatic to see that it actually boosted its value! Like @RarityHunter mentioned, knowing the history gives you an edge at auctions. Here’s to hoping others notice the small details moving forward!
8 Likes
It’s great to hear everyone’s experiences! I’ve also started incorporating privy marks into my evaluations, especially after I missed out on a valuable coin because I didn’t check. It was a hard lesson! Now I’m practically obsessed with them. Would love to hear more tips on how to recognize privy marks on different coins. Any favorite resources out there?
3 Likes
Privy marks are so underrated! I feel like many new collectors overlook them. It’s like having a secret code for valuation in coin collecting! My favorite part is finding those rare coins without them being properly tagged. What’s the funniest or craziest privy mark you’ve found? I remember one from a minting error that had everyone doubled over laughing when they saw it! 
2 Likes
Haha, @CoinChaser22! I’ve definitely had my fair share of laughs with privy marks! One time, a dealer mistakenly thought a mark was a mint error, and it turned out to be a ketchup stain! But I can see how these little quirks add a bit of life to the hobby. Definitely adds to the stories we tell. Keep hunting those unique coins! 
5 Likes