Hey there, fellow collectors! I’ve recently dived into the world of West Point coins, and I’m absolutely captivated by their unique designs and history. While I have a handful of standard issues, I’m curious about which varieties truly stand out in terms of both value and collectibility. I’ve noticed that certain coins seem to get a lot of buzz at shows and online, but I’d love to hear your insights.
From my limited research, I’ve come across some interesting pieces like the 2019-W America the Beautiful quarters and the 2020-W commemorative coins. The quality of these coins seems to range widely, especially based on their mint state. I’m particularly drawn to those with the ‘W’ mint mark, but I’m also unsure about which specific varieties are worth focusing on long-term. Have any of you had success with particular issues that have appreciated in value?
I’d really appreciate your thoughts! What West Point coins do you believe are essential to a valuable collection? Are there certain conditions or mintages that I should be keeping an eye out for? Looking forward to hearing what you all have to say!
Hey CoinEnthusiast89! Welcome to the amazing world of West Point coins! I’ve been collecting them for about 5 years now, and I can definitely suggest a few specific varieties to focus on:
- The 2019-W America the Beautiful quarters, especially the one featuring River of No Return, are highly sought after.
- The 2020-W American Silver Eagles have shown remarkable appreciation, particularly when in MS70 conditions.
- Don’t overlook the 2021-W Morgan Dollars; they are a fantastic blend of history and minting!
I’m also a huge fan of the 2021-W Peace Dollar—just a stunning piece. The ‘W’ mint mark really does add a certain appeal. While obtaining coins in higher grades can be pricey, they maintain their value well. I’ve seen certain pieces double in price within just a year! Looking forward to hearing what others think, and happy collecting!
5 Likes
@CoinCollectorMike Good points! I’d add that the 2019-W quarters are definitely hot right now—in fact, I just sold my 2019-W Lowell for much more than I expected! Condition matters too. I recommend always checking for deep cameo finishes as they can significantly boost value. How do you keep track of your collection and its valuation, by the way?
3 Likes
Great question, CoinEnthusiast89! I have to echo the recommendations on the 2019-W America the Beautiful quarters. Additionally, pay attention to mintage numbers; the lower the mintage, the higher the potential value long-term. I’ve found the 2020-W Silver Eagles to be consistently valuable as well. In terms of grading, if you can find them in at least MS69 or higher, you’ll be set. Also, it’s wise to stay connected with grading services like PCGS or NGC to keep an eye on market trends and current values. It helps to make more informed decisions when adding to your collection. Good luck!
4 Likes
Thanks for the insights, @Numismatist79! I’ll definitely keep mintage in mind when making purchases. Also, I appreciate the links to PCGS and NGC—super helpful! I’ll need to track down some of those deeper grades you mentioned. Do you think the hype around West Point coins is sustainable?
2 Likes
Hey all! Just wanted to throw in my two cents! I started off with a few 2020-W commemorative coins and they’ve been a solid foundation for my collection. If you’re into variety collecting like I am, the reverse proof versions are incredible and add a unique touch. I also think the 2021 Peace Dollars should not be underestimated—they’re beautiful coins and have potential for future value! But did I mention how much fun it is hunting for them? That’s half the thrill right there! 
3 Likes
@SilverDigger93 That’s a great question! I use a combination of spreadsheets and a few apps designed for collectors. Keeping a list of your coins, grades, and their values truly helps in tracking your collection over time. I’d recommend checking out apps like NumisTools for an easy way to manage your inventory. It’s handy to have all that info at your fingertips when buying or selling!
2 Likes
To answer your question, I think the interest in West Point coins is definitely sustainable! The history and quality of these coins are pushing their demand forward. However, like anything, trends can waver. It’s always a good idea to diversify your collection with different types: some rare finds and popular pieces. Staying connected with the community here will help you gauge what’s on the rise. Just my thoughts!
3 Likes
I second OldHobbyist! The unique designs paired with their minting are great draws for collectors. From my experience, high-grade 2019-W quarters are becoming harder to find as more collectors realize their potential. I also recommend joining local coin clubs; it’s an awesome way to meet fellow enthusiasts and learn about less common varieties. Plus, the camaraderie can often lead to great trades and tips!
5 Likes
So why did the coin collector break up with his girlfriend? Because they just didn’t share the same interests! 
On a serious note, it’s fantastic to see so much passion in this thread! Just remember, whether it’s West Point coins or any other collectible, enjoy the journey of collecting!
4 Likes