Hey fellow collectors!
I wanted to share the experience of acquiring my first 1909-S penny, a key date that had been on my wish list for ages. After months of scouring local shops and online auctions, I found a piece in a decent condition—F12 with some nice original patina. I was beyond thrilled, but it sparked a mini obsession about its history and significance. Doing my research, I learned that this coin is famous for being the first year of the Lincoln penny and carries a bit of intrigue due to its low mintage.
That brings me to the discussion point: How much does the story behind a coin influence your collecting habits? I found myself fascinated not just by the coin itself but also by how many hands it has passed through and the eras it has witnessed. Looking back, I’m curious—what’s a memorable first coin acquisition for you all, and how did that shape your collection journey? Also, do you think the historical value of a coin outweighs its condition or rarity? Let’s hear your thoughts!
Happy collecting!
Congrats on the 1909-S! Those pennies are truly special due to their history. I remember when I got my first 1909-S too; it was in G4 condition. It had a very different vibe from modern coins. When I hold it, I imagine the people who once used it—like what they bought or where it traveled. To me, the story behind a coin adds a layer of depth that just the condition can’t match. For example, I also enjoy collecting coins that were in circulation during major events in history. Does anyone else feel that way?
5 Likes
Thanks, @silverhunter22! It really does make you think about the history behind every coin. I didn’t appreciate that aspect until I got my 1909-S. It made me want to research even more about the era and its significance. What are some key historical coins that you’ve come across in your journey?
3 Likes
I totally agree with @silverhunter22! It’s not just a coin; it’s a piece of history. My first memorable acquisition was a 1955 double die penny. I was shocked when I found it in a roll of coins! F12 condition but with a significant market value. The excitement from that find got me into the whole collecting scene more seriously. Anyone else have a story about a surprising find? 
4 Likes
Wow, @coincollector101! A 1955 double die penny is a fantastic find. For me, my first was also a double die, but from 1972. I’ve kept it ever since. The thrill of finding it just might be second to the joy of preserving it. It was my gateway into understanding how condition can greatly affect value, especially for such unique pieces. How do you all feel about grading services like NGC or PCGS? Do you use them for your coins?
6 Likes
Great topic! The story behind a coin definitely influences my collecting! I focus on pieces with historical relevance. For instance, I obtained a 1918 Buffalo nickel recently, and researching its history really enhanced my appreciation for it. I’m curious about what you think—does the rarity of a coin matter more than its story?
2 Likes
Good question, @collectorjoe96! Personally, I think both are crucial. Coin rarity often guarantees its market value, but the story can make it infinitely more valuable personally. I mean, a 1909-S penny is an excellent example. Would you all prioritize a historically valuable coin over a rarer coin in lesser condition? Would love to hear your opinions!
7 Likes
I think the story matters a lot! My first coin was a Wheatie that I found in my grandma’s attic. The sentimental value makes it priceless. I always look for coins related to family history now. 
Does anyone collect based on family stories or connections?
3 Likes
Absolutely, @jackson_coin! That’s a lovely sentiment. I think every collector has a unique journey, and incorporating family stories makes it richer. I’ve tried to keep coins that remind me of family milestones. It adds another layer of significance. How do you all display or store such special pieces? Would love some tips!
5 Likes
I started collecting because of the allure of historical stories! I love the early 1900s coins, especially the Barber dimes. They have amazing designs and fascinating tales. I also think the chase is half the fun—finding hidden gems at estate sales! Have you guys heard about NGC? They have some great resources for collectors seeking history.
6 Likes
Don’t underestimate the condition of a coin, even though historical value is substantial. The 1909-S penny has a great story, but its mintage means nothing if it’s heavily worn. It can still be valuable in AU or MS grades, but a G4 specimen won’t be nearly as desirable. Just my two cents! Anyone else feel preserving condition is key?
4 Likes