Hey everyone! I’ve been diving deeper into error coins lately and I can’t help but wonder if coins submitted in groups tend to get overlooked when it comes to spotting those unique mistakes. I mean, with so many coins being reviewed at once, it seems possible that the details can slip through the cracks.
Recently, I submitted a batch of coins for grading, and amongst them was a shiny 1999 quarter that had an obvious die break. I did my homework by researching error types and found several similar examples online, but the thought of it getting lost among other submissions made me anxious. The coin is in great condition, and I really believe it could be a valuable find if recognized properly.
So, what do you all think? Are error coins often overlooked in larger submissions? What strategies do you use to ensure your potential errors are not missed? Have you ever had a coin that you suspected was an error only to find out it was indeed a significant one? Let’s share some experiences!
Great post, @CoinEnthusiast92! I can definitely relate to your concerns about error coins. In my experience, coins submitted in groups can indeed be overlooked during grading sessions. Grading services like PCGS and NGC have strict protocols, but with many coins on their desks, a unique error might slip through the cracks.
- One strategy I use is to clearly label any coins I believe have potential errors.
- Providing detailed descriptions on the submission form helps as well.
- Reaching out to the grading service ahead of time via customer support has sometimes allowed me to flag specific coins for closer inspection.
Just be diligent and do your research, and don’t hesitate to follow up post-submission!
10 Likes
I agree, @CoinCollector99! It’s a common concern. I once submitted a group of 20 coins, and I had highlighted one with a noticeable doubling. Turns out it didn’t get the attention it deserved. I learned to take good photos beforehand and kept a copy of my notes with the submission. It really helps to battle the uncertainty! 
7 Likes
Thanks for the insights, @NumismaticNerd! I’m planning to document everything meticulously before I send it off next time. It just makes sense! What type of error did yours turn out to be?
5 Likes
To directly address your question, @CoinEnthusiast92, yes, error coins can often be missed in a group submission. I had a memorable experience with a 1982 penny that had a significant over-pressing error. Even though I flagged it, the grading house initially gave it a standard grade. I had to re-submit with additional evidence to get the error acknowledged.
- Always take detailed photos of the errors.
- Include relevant articles or references with your submission.
It’s an extra effort, but it’s worth it in the end!
8 Likes
That’s so frustrating, @RareCoinHunter! It sounds like a hassle to go through re-submissions. I appreciate the tip on including articles; I’ll make sure to do that next time.
4 Likes
As far as spotting errors, it’s a combination of knowledge and experience. I often browse forums and read current blogs about error types to keep myself informed. Each submission is a learning process. And for what it’s worth, if you think a coin has an error, trust your instincts! Recent trends show that more collectors are unearthing valuable mistakes, so don’t let your coin go unexamined. US Mint has excellent resources to help with identification too.
6 Likes
Thanks, @CoinGuru77! I’ll definitely check out more resources, especially from the US Mint. It’s good to know that trusting my instincts could lead to a valuable find.
3 Likes
Does anyone else feel like the grading services are getting a little sloppy with group submissions? I’ve had coins that seemed high-quality returned with basic grades just because they were grouped! Maybe the pressure of volume is overwhelming? 
5 Likes
Totally feel you on that, @PennyPincher42! I think they definitely miss details when they’re swamped. It’s even tougher with errors—those need a trained eye. Best to stay proactive and follow up, like some of us were discussing!
4 Likes
I’ve had the same experience, @PennyPincher42! I’ve seen submissions that clearly contained notable errors returned with just a passing grade. It’s frustrating when you’ve done your homework and still feel like it fell short. I now use follow-ups and don’t hesitate to ask for re-evaluations when I believe something significant was missed!
6 Likes
It’s reassuring to hear I’m not alone in this frustration, @CoinWhisperer! I definitely plan on being more proactive in the future.
3 Likes
I just want to say, @CoinEnthusiast92, that your shiny 1999 quarter sounds like a cool find! Die breaks can be really interesting. Even if it’s overlooked in grading, maybe it’ll become a collector’s item for being unique! Keep us posted on the outcome!
2 Likes