Hey fellow collectors! Lately, I’ve been diving deep into error coins, and I find myself torn between double strikes and other types of errors like brockages and off-centers. Recently, I came across a beautiful 1920-S Mercury dime with a prominent double strike, and I can’t help but marvel at its uniqueness. It got me thinking—what is the current market sentiment toward double strikes compared to other error types?
I’ve done a bit of research, and it seems like double strikes often fetch higher prices at auctions, especially in decent condition. However, I’ve noticed that some collectors seem to prefer the rarity associated with brockages or misaligned dies. From the examples I’ve seen, a well-preserved double strike can tell such an incredible story about the minting process that I think it gives it a special charm. What are your thoughts?
I’d love to hear what you all think! Do you have any examples in your collection that really showcase the appeal of double strikes? Or do you lean more toward other error types? Let’s discuss what you think holds more value in today’s market and why!
Great topic, CoinEnthusiast42! I believe that the value of error types can significantly vary based on collectors’ preferences and market trends. Double strikes, indeed, are often more sought after, especially when they’re in high grades like MS65 or better. I’ve seen some sales where double strikes can go for 2-3 times the price of other errors, such as brockages or off-center strikes.
From personal experience, I own a 1960 double struck Lincoln penny that fetched a nice sum when I sold it last year. On the other hand, a well-executed misaligned die coin from the same year didn’t attract nearly as much interest despite its unique characteristics. By the way, if you are looking for more detailed grading characterization, check out this resource: PCGS CoinFacts.
Looking forward to hearing everyone else’s thoughts!
10 Likes
Thanks for sharing, ErrorSeeker! Your experience with the Lincoln penny really illustrates your point. I also feel that collectors lean towards double strikes because they visually showcase the minting process. But I do wonder if the preference varies across different eras and types. Do you think newer errors are mostly valued less because collectors favor historical pieces?
5 Likes
Interesting! In my experience, I’ve noticed that while double strikes attract premium prices, the story behind brockages often pulls in collectors who appreciate history. My personal fave is a 1942- brockage that not only has captivating visuals but also a great story about wartime minting practices. I think both types hold their own unique charm in the market.
7 Likes
That’s a great question! I think newer errors can still hold some value, but their rarity and uniqueness often don’t compare to vintage errors. Collectors often gravitate towards a history that comes with older errors like double strikes from the 20th century. Maybe it’s the nostalgia factor? Would love to hear other opinions on this.
4 Likes
Hey everyone! I recently picked up a beautiful 1920-S Mercury Dime double strike! I wasn’t sure of its value, but some quick research pointed out that such pieces are quite valuable now. I’m a novice, so what should I look out for in terms of grading and condition?
6 Likes
Glad to hear about your find, DimeFinder2024! For a 1920-S double strike, focus on the surface quality and details. Any wear could dramatically affect value. Look for attributes such as the detail in the face, mint luster, and any scratches. If you have a local coin shop, consider getting a professional grading opinion! Here’s a link that might help you out: NGC for their grading services.
8 Likes
For what it’s worth, I think both double strikes and brockages have their own allure. But the new errors, when they pop up in the market, seem to gain collectors quite rapidly, especially when they’re tied to fun stories or peculiar minting errors. I guess it’s about the narrative sometimes!
3 Likes
Thanks for the tips, NumismatistJack! I just signed up for an account on NGC to get some official info. I will definitely try to find a local coin shop too. Fingers crossed that my dime is worth more than I paid for it!
5 Likes
Just a fun observation! I think there’s an interesting angle to this discussion. How about the miscalled errors? Those can be real gems if they are verified later! I once picked up a coin that the seller thought was a double strike but turned out to be a double-die. Interestingly, it held more sentimental value for me than the price!
4 Likes
Haha NerdyNumismatist, that’s the kind of luck every collector dreams of! It’s such a hit-or-miss sometimes, isn’t it? But it makes collecting all the more exciting with surprises at every turn.
6 Likes